"What, are you going to turn me into a toad now?" I laughed sarcastically.
She smirked, and laughed, "You know it's such a cliché, but I think in your case, spending the rest of your life hopping around croaking would be pretty amusing to me!" she giggles as she points her wand towards me, it starts glowing.
I feel the energy hit my body, making my skin tingle as it becomes bumpy, brown and slimy. My throat swells, and I try to shout for help, only hearing a loud "CROAK!" coming out as she smirks, "That's a nice look for you!" she laughs evilly as I shrink, my fingers becoming webbed, as I shrink smaller and smaller looking up at her, my clothes becoming bigger and bigger on me.
I feel my eyes bulge out, and my tongue rolls out, long and sticky. I keep croaking and trying to get out of my now giant clothes, finally breaking free and hopping out. Now a full toad, I look up at the witch, who has a mirror held out for me so I can see my new slimy toad body. I croak angrily as she shakes her head, "Should've been more careful with your magic! Now you can spend the rest of your life croaking!" she laughs
I look up at her in fear, hoping she will change me back soon, but realizing she planned on keeping me this way. I see her eyes light up, "Oh, one last thing! I think we should make you a horny girl toad" she mischievously laughs as she flicks her wand at me again, my now toad cock shrivelling inside me, leaving me with a wet toad pussy, and an insatiable lust.
"Now we need to find you a new toad lover!" she laughs excitedly, as she looks around, "Actually, I have an even better idea!"