It Christmas and Wyatt takes Penny home for the holidays. Well, their home back in Virginia, before joining the circus. Penny had just turned 17, on December 10th, And she thought her dad is going to reunite her with her mother. Well, her mother's new boyfriend, Andrew. He looked like Sam, but older and mostly bald. Sam still has his short-brown hair. Andrew could be a brother or something.
Anyways, Wyatt knocks on the apartment of his ex wife, and she opens it.
Debra: Wyatt, never thought I'd see you again.
Wyatt: I'm not staying for very long. Penny, however, she misses you and wants to spend more time with you.
Debra looks down at Penny, who looks like a homeless boy, from the streets.
Debra: Well, men should never raise little girls, by themselves. For goodness sake, Wyatt. She looks like a boy.
Wyatt: Well, it keeps the boys away.
Debra: Well, good of you to bring her back. Penny is my daughter.
Then Wyatt faces Penny.
Wyatt: You have fun with your mother, okay. Maybe this is what you need.
Penny: Am I staying for good?
Wyatt: For three months, then I'm picking you up.
Penny: Bye, daddy.
Penny hugs her dad, before she goes inside the apartment with her mom, closing the door. Penny comes into the living room and sees this Andrew, with a big tummy, but still looking good for a bald guy as old as her dad.
Debra: Penny, this is my boyfriend, Andrew. We've been together for a few months. Andrew, this is my daughter, Penny.
Surely, I told you about her.
Andrew: Yeah, you have.
Next to him, a plate of food, and he munches on some chips as he watches TV. Debra takes Penny to show her were she'll be sleeping during her stay. The guest bedroom, whenever Andrew or Debra invite friends over.
Debra: You have any clothes, Penny?
Penny: Just a week's worth of t-shirts, jeans and underwear.
Debra: No bras?
Penny: I don't have much, so I don't wear a bra.
Debra: Poor thing. Tomorrow, I'll take you shopping. Daddy had to make you look like a boy. While you're here, you'll be looking like a woman.
Penny smiles. It felt so good to be back with her mother. Maybe this will solve her fetish problem. Well, maybe. At the dinner table, Andrew wasn't much of a talker, but an eater like her daddy is.
Debra: So, Penny. What have you and daddy been up to?
Penny: We've been traveling with the circus. We were both clowns.
Debra: I'm sure with all the rides, you probably had a lot of fun. What about friends? What about school?
Penny: Just one friend, but then he's my dad's friend, named Sam. As for school, I've been doing it my mail.
Debra: No boyfriend?
Penny: Not really. Dad's always kept an out out for me.
Debra: I was 17 when I met your father. Of course, he was 19, and had you when I was 20.
Penny: No other kids after me?
Debra: Trying to work on a another kid, with Andrew. He has no children and his family don't like to come around. Can't figure out why.
Andrew: I'm right here, you know. And you know why my family don't come around.
Debra: Yeah, but not in front of Penny.
Andrew: Three months, she'll figure it out.
Penny changes the subject.
Penny: So mom, while I'm here, will I get to go to school?
Debra: When was the last time you been to an actual school?
Penny: Before the circus, the last time I been in school, was when I got to finish the 6th grade.
Debra: And he gets sole custody? The man hasn't had you in school for four and a half years. That pisses me off.
Penny: I do wanna go to school. I want friends. I want a normal life. I'm supposed to be a Junior this year and I wanna do teenage things and have a graduation.
Debra: Well, you just turned 17. You have a right in what you wanna do from here on out.
That's when Andrew gets up and is ready to leave the table.
Debra: Where you going, Andrew?
Andrew: To the bathroom. Anything else?
Debra: You're good.
And then he leaves the room and they both hear a door slam.
Penny: Do I wanna know?
Debra: Not really, Penny.
The next afternoon, Debra has took her daughter shopping, for age appropiate girl clothes. Penny has an A-Cup, but her mom got her bras, anyways.
Debra: Don't ever wish your boobs have gotten bigger?
Penny: I didn't think it mattered.
Debra: Most men like something they could grab, that's all.
Penny: Well, then those men are very picky. I want someone who is sweet, nice, respectful and confident.
Debra: Good luck with that. What about looks?
Penny: Should looks matter? If he's physically attractive, then every woman would wanna jump him, and I don't want baggage.
Debra: Well you've been at the circus too long, and seen a lot of freaks, and you feel empathy for them. I guess that's understandable.
Penny: Well, not physically a freak. I just prefer the simple guys.
Debra: Not any simple guys at the circus?
Penny: Dad was always around and overprotective. That, and he made sure I always stayed busy, to have time for making friends.
Debra: Well, if you live with me, I'll make sure you'll have friends.
Then Penny hugs her mom. But that night, she kinda missed Sam, and did something to remember him by the one thing they had in common. She had been holding her bowels, all day, careful not to lose it in fron of her mother. She usually wasn't shy, about messing her pants, but this is a different situation. In the middle of the night, she went into the bathroom, closing the door. She lifted up her night gown, exposing her panties to the bathroom mirror, and leaned on the counter for support. She grunted and felt a long soft turd, slid out into her panties.
Feeling very stimulated, she stuck her right hand in front of her panties to finger herself, and the other hand rubbing the bulge behind her. She thought, if she just an orgasm, she would clean up and go to bed and no one would know what she had done. Wrong. Andrew came in, for a midnight piss in the toilet, and saw her. Penny never felt more embarrassed. It was like, if she were being caught, by her dad.
Andrew: Still not used to having a third person in the house.
Penny: Don't tell my mom. It's not what you think.
Andrew: Well, I have to piss. Can you be quick?
Then Andrew closes the door. Penny was to horrified to finish with having an orgasm. Andrew had killed the mood, so she dumps her firm load in the toilet, flushes and leaves the bathroom. It was hard for her to sleep, worried that Andrew will tell her mom, what he caught her doing. Her mom appears to be disgusted about what wasn't lady-like.
The next morning, it happens to be awkward silence at the breakfast table. Debra breaks the silence.
Debra: Well, I'm working til 4 today. When do you gotta work, Andrew?
Andrew: I go in at 5, then coming home at midnight.
Penny: What do you guys do?
Debra: I have an office job and Andrew works construction. Explains his fashion for flannel shirts, blue jeans and work boots.
Penny: At least I won't be alone.
Debra: Well, there will be times where we work a lot, so you gotta help out with cleaning the house and making dinner.
Penny: No problem.
Shortly after Debra leaves, this leaves Penny alone with Andrew, which she dreaded. The next seven hours were gonna be awkward. She just wanted to watch TV, no conversation with Andrew, as he sat across from her.
Andrew: I didn't tell your mother, Penny.
Penny: You could have. I don't even know you. Can we not talk about it?
Andrew: Don't be embarrassed. If you knew my secret, you'd feel better about yourself.
Penny: (scoffs) Spare me the lecture on having a scat fetish, okay. I've been doing it since I was six years old. Not something I share with everyone.
Andrew: Of course, not. Your mom would say, it isn't lady-like, for a woman to mess her panties. Me, I have other ideas.
Penny is now curious about Andrew. Man, he's looking good in that flannel shirt, blue jeans and the rugged look of having beard stubbles on his face.
Penny: What is your secret, huh? You like to watch women mess their pants?
Andrew: Girl, I mess my pants, too. Your mom knows, but she knows that men have some gross behavior. I tried asking your mom, if she'd shit her panties for me, but she wouldn't have it. To walk in on a woman, with shit in her panties and finger in her pussy, would be a dream.
Penny: Honestly, you got off on what you saw last night?
Andrew: As if you were a random woman, sure.
Penny: Well, I haven't been here a week, and haven't seen you poop your pants.
Andrew: I didn't know you, Penny. I was being polite. Tomorrow, I should take you out, and show you the real me.
Penny: (confused) The real you?
Andrew: I'm a heavy eater, so I always have a colon full of shit, and always shitting my pants and letting them get full to the brim. I would also eat, while shitting my pants, at the same time.
Penny: And no one smells you in public?
Andrew: I'm immune to it, not caring what people think. And this will be a first, to have someone with me, that would wanna sit on my lap and wanna fuck me, while I have shit in my pants.
Penny: How you know that I'm attracted to you?
Andrew: Are you? You were checking me out, the moment we met.
Penny: So, I like older men, and want my first time to be with an older man.
Andrew: 17 is practically the new 18. So, would you like to go out with me?
Penny: What about my mother? What would she think?
Andrew: Let's not tell her. And besides, would it turn you on, if you had a man that shit his pants in public?
Penny: What does my mom think about your fetish?
Andrew: She tolerates it and not kinky to any of it.
Penny changes the subject.
Penny: So, what do we do today? If not watch you completely mess your pants in public?
Andrew gets up and sits next to Penny, putting his right arm around her. She is actually liking where her and Andrew are going. He seems sexual, confident and respectful. The kinda man she wants. His lips are looking quite kissable and wanting.
Penny: Damn, you look good. Do you compensate for the size of your dick?
Andrew: Quite a dirty mouth for a virgin.
Penny: Okay, so I've seen a lot of action at the circus, and like the balancing act of a limber woman balancing on a strong man's cock.
Andrew: So when the curtain goes down, it's pretty much a midnight orgy, huh?
Penny: Pretty much. I've watched, but never participated. My dad would've flipped if a guy even looked at me the wrong way.
Andrew: To bad, cause I like you. In the meantime, it's best to get to know each other first, before we move on to the really kinky stuff.
Penny: I'm sure it would be worth the wait.
The both them only sat and talked, or walked around and talked, but nothing that involved intimite touching and kissing. They were saving on that.
The next day, while Debra was at work, Andrew drove Penny to town, and where there was a Ponderosa buffet. It was a cold day, but neither of them didn't mind. He was about to keep himself warm. At the buffet, and sitting at a table, Andrew felt the pressure building in his colon. While she continued eating, she would causally look behind him, and noticed a slight bulge in the back of his jeans. She starts feeling moist, between her legs, knowing that he just pooped his pants in public.
Andrew: I'm not done, if that's what you're thinking.
Penny: No, but I'm getting excited.
When he smiled and put his left hand on her leg, he shifted in his seat to pass gas, which only leaked a small amout of mushy poop in his blue boxer briefs.
Andrew: I need to get more food. Wanna join me? I'm gonna loading my pants as I load up my plate.
That made Penny even more excited. She really wanted to see him make a big load in his pants. She smiles, gets up with him, a small soft turd pushed into his blue undies. Penny wasn't that hungry, only getting a small plate, and watched as he loaded up his. After all, he was a competitive eater, like her dad. Grabbing some salad, she watched as he pushed out a thick, firm turd in his undies, before sitting down.
Back at their table, with their plates of food, he pushed out a small firm turd into his undies. When he sat down, the feeling of all that poop squishing in his butt, felt wonderful. Penny was already filling up and continued to watch Andrew eat.
Penny: I like it when a man eats a lot. My dad was a competitive eater.
Andrew: Yeah, but does he shit his pants, while he's eating?
Penny: Not really.
Sitting down, with already a decisive bulge, he feels another turd ready to come out. He did lift his butt up, as he continued eating, and Penny watched as his bulge slowly grew. His undies filling with soft poop, Penny isn't sure how much his undies could hold. She sat at the edge of her seat, torturous not to finger herself, and he continued to push soft turds into his pants.
Penny: Damn, Andrew. I'm getting horny as I watch.
Andrew: My dick is also getting hard. After I'm done, we go back to the apartment, and I fuck you with my pants full of shit.
Penny: Oh, yes. Talk dirty to me, you sexy man. I'm wet down there. It's hard not to pleasure myself in public.
Andrew's bulge is now the size of a melon, when he sits back down, but he isn't done.
Penny: Is that all? Cause that looks like a lot, not that I'm complaining. I get turned on by big loads.
Andrew: I'm not done.
He raises his butt up, passes gas, pushing out three cucumber sized turds into his undies, inflating them even more to create a bulge as large as a football in the seat of his undies. Then he sits back down, squishing the big pile of poop, against his butt, up his crack and between his legs.
Andrew: I'm done, now. Let's go back to the apartment and have some fun.
Getting out to the car, he felt the need to poop again, pushing a couple of banana-sized turds in his undies. Driving back, all Penny could do, was stare at his crotch and fantasize about his dick in her pussy.
Inside the apartment, closing the door, Andrew take off his clothes. Penny is overwhelmed by the sight of Andrew's soiled underpants.
Penny: You made a big mess.
Andrew: It's not the biggest mess I ever made.
Penny: I find that hard to believe.
Andrew starts messaging his cock, through his undies, while his other hand cupped the poopy bulge behind him. Andrew moaned, pushing hard on the bulge, and felt poop spreading all over his butt.
Penny: Now, you're making me horny. I wanna see your big dick.
Andrew: You will. All nine inches of it.
Andrew pulls his cock out of his messy undies, and her mouth drops, at the sight of his length and girth. Her hand trembles, just as she reaches out to touch it.
Penny: You know, I wasn't lying, when I said that I'm a virgin and wanted you to be my first.
Andrew: I never thought you were dishonest with me.
Penny: Damn, you're sexy right now.
Andrew rapidly messaged his cock, feeling orgasmic, as he starts smearing the poop all over his butt.
Andrew: I'm naughty, Penny. I took a big shit, in my pants, and I'm getting myself all dirty.
Penny: You want me to spank you, Andrew?
Andrew: If you want. Spank my dirty bottom, I mean.
Andrew was surprised that he wasn't freaking her out. Andrew sat on the floor, pulling on his dirty cock. Andrew was sliding his butt, back and forth on the floor, making a bigger mess. Penny got closer to him, kneeling beside him, slowly putting her hand on the tip of his cock. Her other hand, touched his face, then kissing him. The kiss was so intense, as it deepened with their tongues, that he had an orgasm. If anyone could get Andrew to come, with just a kiss, it just happens to be Penny.
Penny starts feeling around for his balls, getting her right hand all dirty, and whispers to him.
Penny: Man, you so hot and sexy. I want your dick inside me. I want to have an orgasm.
Andrew: I don't have a condom.
Penny: I thought you wanted to do this.
Penny stood up, to take off her clothes, only leaving her bra on. She lays back, on the floor, with her legs spread open for him. Could this be a dream? Is Andrew really seeing this girl, laying naked in front of him, and wanting his dick inside her? A woman who also enjoys pooping in her panties? Andrew gets on his knees and positions himself in front of her.
She threw her head back, just as she felt his cock enter her virgin pussy, and let out a scream in pain. Andrew tried to be careful, slowly thrusting in and out, but she wanted more. She moaned for more. Her legs, wrapped around his waist, to drive him deeper inside of her. Since it is her first time, he wanted to make it special, and fucked as hard, fast and deep as he could. The harder he rammed her, the louder she moaned. Moaning out his name.
Penny: Oh yes, Andrew! Right there! Oh yes!
Andrew pumped into her, irractically, til they both came. Then he pulled out and laid beside her.
Penny: I wish this moment didn't have to end.
Andrew: Me neither. It was the best fuck I ever had. That, and I need to clean up, before your mother gets home.
Penny: Well, you did make a big mess.
Clean up was an issue, but what could he do? He had to clean the floor of the apartment before Debra came home. A month later, Debra had came home early, and saw the two of them fucking in a shitty mess. She got mad and threw them both out on their asses, disowning her own daughter for stealing her boyfriend. On top of that, Penny ends up pregnant by Andrew. Penny wonders how her dad would feel about this.