Andy made his way back towards the party. He had snorted, smoked, drank all sorts of substances but had never felt a high like this before. He didn't want it to stop, he wanted more, he needed more. The party was in full swing, if he chose right he was sure he could get at least one more in. Andy felt light and strong, he had been drinking but his mind was still nimble weighing the pros and cons of each potential victim. He made his way to the kitchen and posted up against the counter until he saw Chuck and Nick heading into the garage. Probably to smoke he thought to himself. Andy didn't have a plan, but he figured at least he had two of them alone, maybe he think something up.
Andy walked into the garage a few moments after Chuck and Nick and found them packing a pipe to smoke some pot. "Hey guys," he said cooly, "mind if I join you?" The two looked at each other and offered "fine" back in unison before lighting up and passing. Chuck was just shy of 6'6" and the star senior on the basketball team. He was a jock in every sense of the word, muscular and athletic, even down to terrorizing people that didn't meet his definition of cool. Andy had generally avoided his wrath because he sold pot to Chuck. Chuck had one other thing that Andy was after tonight, a really big penis. Chuck was proud of his massive appendage, taking any opportunity he got to whip it out. Last week, he grabbed a freshman who hadn't changed fast enough's shoes and peed in them right in front of the poor kid, making him watch the whole time. Estimates ranged but the consensus was Chuck was easily in the double digits hard. Nick was taller than Andy but shorter than Chuck, closer to 5'10. He was a senior too but didn't make the cut to the varsity basketball team so he quit. Andy didn't know Nick's heritage but he guessed he was mixed race, his dark features made him a hit with the ladies, despite not being in stellar shape.
The pipe went around a few times, before Andy thought of how he'd approach this situation. "Chuck, man," he started trying to sound innocent, "I've heard you've got a big tool," pointing to Chuck's crotch, "I bet I'm bigger." Chuck gave him a quizzical look that clearly conveyed a "what the fuck" to Andy, Nick started coughing on the smoke he'd just taken in. Andy figured his ploy hadn't worked just when Chuck answered him, "Ahh yea I do, and maybe you stop smoking, you musta had too much." Andy doubled down, "I bet I'm bigger than both of you." Nick and Chuck looked at each other before Nick spoke, "I can't tell if you just want to see my Dick or feel bad about yourself, either way its not going to happen." Andy couldn't help himself, "Yea, Elly told everyone that your nose is bigger than your dick, so I get why you're out." Nick looked pissed, but Chuck laughed and confirmed that that was the rumor going around. "Fine, homo, lets do this" Nick spat through clench teeth. Andy was going on instinct. The three boys stood in a triangle towards the back of the garage and started to open up their pants. Andy huddled in close, "for a side by side comparison" he offered to no one as he did so. As soon as the three dicks were out and next to each other, Chuck started to say something about being the winner, but Andy was already dropping to his knees. He grabbed both dicks, which instantly became erect with his touch and jammed them into his mouth. The rumors about both boys were true and Andy's mouth felt like it was going to rip wider trying to accommodate Chuck's monster next to Nick's 3" incher. Chuck started to pump his hips slightly moaning a little which knocked Nicks member out of Andy's mouth, the spell that bound him started to wear off Nick who slowly began to realize what was happening and fight it. Andy grabbed Nick's ass and forced his hips forward and cock back into Andy's mouth just as Chuck began to cum with nick following soon behind. Andy struggled to keep all of the cum in his mouth, he choked it down greedily. When the process was done he pulled his head to the now predictable results. Both of the once proud guys now looked drained. Nick's small unit now barely made it out of his body. Andy rushed from the garage barely able to contain his excitement, wanting to see what his gains would be.