Alyssa Cooper stared at the two teenagers with lust in her eyes, knowing that as active weres, they were legal according to Moon Lake law, but the rules concerning sex with a minor would prohibit her from doing anything she was thinking about elsewhere in the country.
She was still in a bit of shock that Marty Stovall had turned her down, although the jury was still out on whether or not his wife Melissa would take her up on her offer of experiencing another woman.
Yet here was Marty's delectable young daughter Julie, herself the spitting image of Melissa, along with some were-otter she didn't know, but his hard cock showed he was highly interested in a potential threesome with the two were-mermaids.
"So..." began Alyssa, as she extended her hands. One began caressing the were-otter's penis while the other started teasing the outer lips of Julie's vagina. "Have you two been with other partners before, let alone done a threesome before now?"
Brian Walker, were-otter, reluctantly admitted he hadn't, but that didn't curb his enthusiasm from wanting to try the event.
Julie just smiled. "I've had other boys, and men before," she said, not caring how Brian might react to that news, "but not another woman. Until now," she added, moving closer so Alyssa could have better access to her clit.
"OKAY!" said Alyssa with a smile, while shifting from Phase 3 (full fish tail) to Phase 2, where her tail split back into separate legs, but remained scaly with flippers for feet. "Just join in where you can stud," she told the were-otter, still not having been formally introduced to Brian yet.
With that, Alyssa wiggled her ass seductively at the were-otter as she lowered her head and started licking around the outer folds of Julie's cunt, before moving her experienced tongue deeper inside Julie's pussy.
The hot blooded were-mermaid was no stranger to oral sex, but Julie instantly knew that this was different. Alyssa, or perhaps all women, knew what to do with a cunt because they probably all wished every man was wise enough to treat theirs the same way.
Whether in part because of the stimulation she had already received from Brian, or just because of Alyssa's own talents, it didn't take long for Julie to experience a mind blowing orgasm as the older were-mermaid kept lapping at her pussy even as Alyssa began teasing Julie's clit.
Meanwhile, not to be outdone, after surfacing just long enough for a fresh breath, Brian moved down between Alyssa's legs and started tasting the new were-mermaid's pussy.
Her cunt was different than Julie's. Brian was hesitant to say it was a more mature taste, despite being with an adult woman for the first time. Yet whatever the reason for the difference, he couldn't get enough and wanted much more!
Soon both women were experiencing sexual ecstasy, despite the fact that they had yet to do each other.
Alyssa saw Julie had a smile on her face as big as her own as she moved to kiss the younger were-mermaid.
Brian couldn't wait to fuck either or both of them as he briefly surfaced for more oxygen, since his underwater breathing capacity was minute compared to theirs.
But when he came back down to rejoin the ladies, he was far from happy.
"Julie, I just saw your folks car approaching the shoreline!" he shouted.
"DAMN!" screamed Julie, reluctantly breaking away from Alyssa's embrace.
"Okay, I've got a plan, but we'll have to act fast," announced Alyssa, sad to see the menage a trois end so abruptly.