"...wish that you would fall in love with me." She looked you up and down. "I love you, and there's nothing that's going to change that, but so far it's just been a way for you to control me. I need something a bit more from you. I'm not saying you have to stop seeing other women, because I'm sure not going to, but being in love with you and knowing that you're not really in love with me hurts." Lauren moved even closer to you so that now her naked body was pressed up against you. "The way I see it you have two options. You can either make a wish to make me not be bothered by all of this, which means that I'm basically a sex slave and you don't really care about what I feel, or you can wish to be as in love with me as I am with you and prove that you actually care about me as a person to some degree."
You looked at Lauren and blinked. This was quite a bit. You could make yourself love her, but did that mean that you'd be giving her more power? She already had the basketball team and Veronica, this could easily be a power play on her part, some way to get control over you. On the other hand this could just as easily be an actual plea for you to treat her as an equal. It could be an opportunity for you to be able to have more with Lauren besides sex.
You took a deep breath and said "I wish..."