"I wish I didn't have a hot brother." Cici said.
The tape wound back and played:
"I wish I didn't have just one hot brother."
Reality shifted as seemingly nothing changed. Then, a voice began talking in the other room.
"Okay, just finished gathering stuff from the Thieve's Den, now I just need to get out of here annnd...."
You and Cici go up to see a guy your age sitting at a PC with a webcam. He's got black hair, a build like yours minus a few inches in height, and he's mashing on a game controller while trying to get away from a Sabertooth Tiger in that one game.... Skydim? Flyrim? The one with the horned helmet.
"NO NO NO NO NO... AAAAAAAAAGH!" He yelled as the big cat flung his cat person guy across the screen and it faded to black.
"I'm gonna fast travel to Windhelm and I'll see you next time, bye!" the guy said as he got to the town, saved, and quit.
He turned around to show his short black beard and sparkling blue eyes.
"Hey bro, hey Cici, what's up?" he said.
Then it all becomes clear as memories enter your head: This guy is Colin, your younger brother and Cici's twin. He was smarter than you, but it was the difference between a C student and a B student. He was always a goofball and never shut up about videogames. When puberty hit, he got ripped, and your mom got him his webcam so that he could be a youtube gamer. He called himself "Snub Manatee" (God knows why) and became really popular, almost as much as the pink mustache guy that screamed at those pizzeria robots like a little girl.
"Heya, Brobro." Cici said as she kissed him on the cheek.
"How's it hanging?" Colin said.
"Super. (y/n) found this neat tape recorder. It makes wishes come true." Cici said as she showed him.
"Yeah right, you guys are just messing with me." Colin said.
Cici pouted, "Awwww come on, have a little fun...."
Colin paused, and said, "Alright, let me try this out."
You thought something was wrong as Colin made his wish.
"I wiiiish..."
You knew something was wrong as Colin wished...