You looked yourself in the eyes. More specifically, your male self looked at your female self's eyes, and your female self looked at your male self's eyes.
It wasn't right. It felt... incomplete. Sure, you had the body of the woman you had been dreaming of and crushing on for years, but this wasn't her. You didn't just want to have sex with her, you wanted to be with her romantically and intelligently. The erection in your pants reminded you that she was incredibly attractive. And by the nature of being an identical clone, the girl you is also incredibly attractive. But she/you isn't your dream girl.
You stepped both bodies back from each other and turned to face your girlfriend's 4 bodies (one of whom was naked). "I... I can't. This isn't right." Your masculine voice faded into silence. You watched her 4 faces, hoping to gauge her reaction. The silence hung in the air. She stared at you, incredulous and unmoving.
The silence quickly became uncomfortable. Desperate to break the silence, you spoke with your girl body, "It's not you. You're very sexy. I mean, look at you... Look at me! You're a knockout! But I'm not you. And I want my first time to be with you. Truly with you. Not with some clone that I control."
Tears welled up in your girlfriend's many eyes. Her stunned expressions faded into amazing smiles. "YES!" 2 of her leaped forward at you, colliding with both of your bodies and locking your lips with passionate kisses. Her other 2 bodies spoke to you while she kissed you, "I suspected you truly loved me. And you proved it! You love me for who I am, not just my body. Bodies! Fuck it! Fuck me!"
She tore at the clothes on your male body, quickly removing your t-shirt and undoing the zipper on your jeans. A second her rushed over to your male body and embraced you from the side. At the same time, her other 2 bodies were embracing your already naked female body and already had you on your back on the floor. Her naked body straddled your female face and you reached your tongue out to taste her vagina. You shuddered in anticipation and excitement as a tongue made contact with your vagina.
Your penis reacted vigorously to the stimulation your female body received, quickly becoming fully erect. One of your girlfriends finally got ahold of your pant belt buckets and pulled your pants off, releasing your penis. Another of your girlfriends had her mouth around it in seconds. She clumsily but enthusiastically sucked at the tip, then licked it up and down the shaft. As she knelt at your waist, the girlfriend that had undone your pants stepped in front of your male body and quickly shook off her shirt and bra. You groped her breasts as her lips explored your neck.
A rising flood of pleasure suddenly overwhelmed your female body as you suddenly reached orgasm. Your first female orgasm. You spasmed in surprise and pleasure, shaking both girlfriends above your female body. The one whose vagina you had been teasing with your tongue fell down onto your face, pushing your tongue up into her and eliciting a squeal from her. The other intensified the ministrations of her tongue, drawing out even more pleasure.
Your penis throbbed as you neared ejaculation. You reached down with one hand and tapped your girlfriend on the shoulder, the one that had been stimulating it. She stopped teasing your penis and instead reached over to the other girlfriend next to her, the one who was kissing you on the neck. She pulled down her other body's pants, and rolled back. Her other body pushed her pelvis forward until you entered her. She kept pushing, thrusting her hips as far onto you as she could. At the same time, you thrust into her.
In a burst of intensity, you came inside of her. She gasped and moaned in pleasure. It felt like you would never stop cumming. At the same time that you cummed, your girl self found just the right spot in the girlfriend sitting on her face. Her dual moans of pleasure quickly turned into 4 echoed orgasmic shrieks.
2 of the shrieks suddenly cut short. Your male body looked at the body you had just made a woman, and saw her eyes roll up into her skull. Reflexively, you reached behind and under her arms and grabbed her as she fell. The girlfriend who had orgasmed over your girl body fared worse as her legs gave out and she slid off you to the side. She came to a rest, breathing heavily but otherwise motionless on the floor.
With both bodies, you looked at your girlfriend's 2 remaining bodies. "You okay?" you asked with both voices, barely able to make it out past the raw pleasure bombarding your mind.
"Yes..." came the faintly echoed reply. The beautiful smiles on her faces confirmed the bliss she was experiencing. She slowly moved her remaining bodies onto the floor and a nearby chair, and you did the same thing. You and she sat there in silence and let the intense feelings slowly fade until your mind was again capable of thought, instead of being lost in a sea of doubled pleasure.
Minutes passed before you were able to think straight again. When you did, a sudden realization hit you. "Oh shit. I didn't use protection." You looked at your girlfriend sitting across the table from you, then at her unconscious body sitting next to you. The one you had potentially just impregnated.
"Good. I hoped you wouldn't."
"What? Whoa, aren't you rushing into that? I mean, we aren't even 18 yet."
She laughed, an echoing laugh that came from across the table and on from the floor where she lay. She spoke from the floor, "No, no. Clones can't get pregnant. It was in the list of complications on the terminal."
You looked back at the snoozing girl sitting next to you. She was identical to your other girlfriend's bodies, at least from what you could see. "So this you is a clone. Which you is the original?"
She grinned across the table at you, a mischievous grin that told you she would make sure you would have to pay dearly to find out. "Okay, nevermind. But uh... are you sure you're okay? I mean, you're kinda passed out."
"I think so. You made me orgasm twice at the same time. It was... it was kind of an overload. I felt it in all 4 minds. And then felt myself feeling it. And it kinda feedback looped back until I passed out."
"That sounds like it could be a problem."
"I don't think so. It was amazing. I'm also still new to this. Pretty sure that with some time, I'll learn how to control what sensations get shifted to brains in different bodies."
What she was saying didn't line up with your experience. You definitely didn't feel like you had 2 brains. On the contrary, it felt like you were constantly scrambling to control 2 bodies with 1 brain. "So uh... maybe not the best time to bring this up. But I'm pretty sure I don't have 2 brains?"
The eyelids on the sleeping girl next to you fluttered open and she blinked a few times and looked around. The girl sitting opposite the table answered, "See, I'm fine. But yeah, you're setup uh... differently than me."