Tyler didn't need to be told to continue, he knew that he had to keep spinning until he got that Original Body panel. All he'd need to do is grit his teeth and get through it.
Horse forelegs
Off to a bad start. His fingers crumpled into a black mass as layer of black hair covered his arms. More notably, his arms grew much longer than they started, practically reaching the same length as his legs. He was now too close to the Wheel to properly spin it, so he pulled himself back into a quadrupedal stance. Alarmingly, it felt much more natural once he was back on all fours, so Tyler decided against pulling himself into an upright position. He'd tuned Madame Illusia out, opting to spin again.
Hippo Torso
That can't be good. He'd already had a layer of blubber, but his chest barreled outward shockingly far, widening his stance by a noticeable margin. Tyler noticed the muscles of his legs expand, which was a godsend considering how much weight he must've put on. It was much harder for him to move his chest. What's more, now he was a human head attached to an entirely bestial body.
Cobra Head
He'd just fixed that! Scales covered Tyler's face while his eyelids fused shut, only for them to become transparent a few moments later. His teeth began to travel deeper into his mouth and into his throat. His neck lengthened to nearly 2 feet as the flesh started pulling away into a hood. Two large fangs grew in as his face pushed once more into a snout. A forked tongue flicked out of Tyler's mouth, which surprised him as he didn't do that intentionally. He accidentally licked the Wheel in the process.
As Tyler tried to spin the Wheel once more, his body ceased to respond, freezing him in place. Against his will, he turned away from the wheel, toward Madame Illusia.
She glared daggers at him through a smiling face. "It seems Tyler was far too excited, and forgot to wait until I asked him to spin. And now, his humanity has been lost entirely. Normally, my game is over when such happens, but today is Tyler's lucky day!" The crowd was a mix of cheers and gasps. "I'm going to give Tyler three more chances to return to humanity! After that, he'll be stuck with the body he gets, regardless of what it is!"
Tyler looked on in horror. He only had three chances to fix himself? It was just a game of numbers before, but with so few chances, there was a very real chance he'd be stuck like this forever. What would he do then?
Madame Illusia turned back from the crowd. "Go on, Tyler. Take your final spins."