You follow Melissa's gaze to the flashlight still gripped in your hand. "Oh, just some toy I found in a store," you say, going for a dismissive tone. You try to slip it into your pocket, but Melissa's hand moves quickly away from your crotch and snatches the flashlight. You try to grab it back but she holds it out of reach as she looks it over.
"I've seen this before," she says excitedly. "From that magic shop, right?" You have a sudden sinking feeling. She knows about the flashlight?
"I don't know," you attempt to lie again. "I just found it lying on the floor." At your words, Melissa refocuses on you and her smile disappears.
"You're lying," she said. "Why are you lying? Have you already used this?" You can't help but glance over at Gene, and Melissa follows your gaze. "Of course," she mutters. "I knew it was weird for Gene to have a pussy, but I always remembered..." She suddenly glares at you. "You didn't use this on me, did you?"
"No," you say quickly. "I just tried it a little bit on Gene."
"Tried what on Gene?" Gene asks as he comes back with Melissa's drink.