"It's so weird that he won't notice that there's two girls here now instead of a girl and a guy," you remark quietly.
"I don't know what you mean," Melissa says from behind you. You catch a flash of blue out of the corner of you eye and turn slightly, the flashlight isn't even in sight.
"It's just weird," you say. "I mean, we know he left the table with two guys here and now there's a guy and a girl, but *he* doesn't know that." You frown slightly. Is there something off about Mike?
"Here you go, babe," Gene says, and as you turn back towards him you find his face inches from yours. Before you can do anything he leans in and kisses you. At first you're too surprised to do anything, plus your new lips are softer and more sensual in a kiss. Neither of you notice another blue flash of light. After a moment though you manage to pull yourself away, but Gene simply slides into the booth across from you. Then he notices the look on your face. "What's wrong, did Mike try to make a pass at you?"
Your laugh is genuine. Mike wouldn't make a pass at you because *he* knows that you're not actually a girl. But maybe the same reality change that made Gene suspicious of Mike also made him aware of that time back in high school when Mike thought he could "try out" your pussy. But wait, Mike had said that wasn't real. But how could you know what's real and what's not? You quickly try to take stock.
You're a guy, of course, and according to Mike you're fully a guy (even though you always remember having a pussy - hopefully he'll follow through on his promise to fix that later), but Mike changed you into a girl and was kind enough to let you keep aware of that. Mike's a guy and always has been, since no one used the flashlight on him. Gene's a guy, but...well, you remember using the flashlight on him, but you can't remember what it was. You thought it was on his crotch, but you don't remember him ever having anything but his oversized male package. Maybe he had actually been born with a pussy? Yes, that's it. He had a pussy and you made it into a massive cock. The memory seems to fit.
"Hello!" Gene said. "Earth to Erica!" He laughed when you looked at him in confusion.
"What?" you ask.
"I asked if you want to head back to the dorm," Gene said. He winked, and you realize what he means to do. Part of you is immediately repelled by the idea, but the other part - a large part - finds the idea...intriguing. You glance at Mike, though, and realize he looks a little irritated.
"I thought we were going to hang out," Mike said.
"Sorry, Mike," you tease. "I think Gene prefers girls in his dorm." You just mean to tease him that he could turn into a girl if he really wanted, but when he raises the flashlight and aims it at you, you realize he misunderstood.
"Oh, does he?" Mike says with a smirk.