As Tyler licked his lips staring at the large package that was making its way towards him, he realized he couldn't decide where to go. Finally, he reasoned that the answer was simple: the genie could simply figure it out for him."Johnny, we totally need a change in scenery for this part of the show. I wish I knew the totes best place to have my first time," Tyler wished.
Johnathan was feeling slightly vengeful over the boy's prior resistance, so he wanted make sure the twink became as slutty as possible. Time reversed and Tyler now said, "I wish I knew the totes best place to have my first time WAS RIGHT HERE."
Immediately, Tyler's hesistation diminished. What better place to break his vows than the place he made them, right? As Riley closed the distance between himself and the twink, Tyler realized this was the perfect place for his first time. Without any resistance, the brunette moved away from Calvin's arms so that the redhead could easily slide Tyler's pink jockstrap down his smooth legs and toss them aside, leaving Tyler completely naked in front of his classmates, his anticipation immeasurable.
Meanwhile, Riley began freaking out even more. Was he about to fuck this fag, he thought to himself. No, he couldn't! He was straight! He had a girlfriend named Stacy who was the perfect package for him. Hell, even her attitude was just as bad as his. He wouldn't cheat on her, right? His hands, which were sliding his own gray jockstrap down his hairy legs, seemed to disagree. This sent a panic attack through his system that he couldn't ignore.
"What the fuck? I ain't fucking no fag! Let me fucking go!" Riley roared in vain. The redhead might've found his voice, but he was still in no control of his limbs. He desperately looked around the room, hoping someone would come to his aid. There had to be someone who didn't want to see him have sex like this. If only his coach were here, he'd knock some sense into this faggot. At the very least, his former teammates would be able to help him, right?
Unfortunately, pretty much everyone in the room was less focused on Riley's face and words and more focused on what was down below. After all, as long as they were in the church, they were devoted to big cock, and Riley's massive 10" rod definitely counted. Nearly everyone was at loss for words as they watched the meat bob up and down as the redhead positioned himself behind Tyler and removed the butt plug from the brunette's now soaking wet boypussy. Even Riley would've been entranced by his own package had there not been more pressing issues on his mind.
"Hey, asshole! Let me go or I promise you'll regret it!" Riley yelled, the fury clear on his face. This finally snapped Tyler, who was transfixed on the cock about to enter him, out of his reverie for a second. Analyzing the situation, he realized what he needed to do.
"Hey Johnny, I wish that, like, as Riley fucked me, he turned more and more gay and would start liking it," Tyler exclaimed, excited for what was to come.
Johnathan, liking where this was going, simply made a few extra tweaks to further his goal. "I wish that, like, as Riley fucked me, he turned more and more SLUTTY, gay AND TWINKY and would start liking it," Tyler now said.
As the genie's eyes glowed, Tyler's previous wish began coming into effect as Riley pushed Tyler onto his hands and knees and eased his cock into Tyler's needy hole. Immediately, Tyler knew he'd made the right choice. No plug could've felt this good. Tyler had never felt more full in his life. It couldn't get much better than this, Tyler thought to himself.
He was proven wrong, however, as the redhead began thrusting. Suddenly, every sensation felt a million times better and Tyler wanted more. It was like every feeling was amplified tenfold and the brunette twink was hyperaware of every pleasurable wave that emanated from his hole as it surged throughout his body until it made its way to his head, where it solidified as a loud, slutty moan. Man, his boypussy was needy, Tyler thought as he continued to squirm, hump and moan on the massive rod he was attached to, losing himself to the sensations.
Riley, on the other hand, was speechless. Here he was, fucking the school's weirdo in front of his entire class and it somehow felt... good? Riley had never had a gay thought in his life, but right now, he couldn't deny that the brunette's ass felt amazing. It was almost better than his girlfriend Sarah's. Wait wasn't her name Stacy? Did he care? Less and less as time progressed, he realized.
As per the other part of Tyler's previous wish, Riley began showing off just as he was told, making sure the entire audience got a view of his thick cock and buff body, flexing and even winking at certain audience members who managed to tear their eyes away from the redhead's massive schlong. Inside, he struggled in vain to prevent himself from doing this, but unfortunately he couldn't stop himself and it seemed like no one wanted him to. In fact, many of the audience members in the back even began getting up so as to get a better view of the performance, which both participants had really started to get into based on their lewd faces and loud moans. Everyone wanted a glimpse of the massive cock before them and were insanely curious over it being shown off.
In fact, they were so obsessed with it that they didn't even notice the rest of Riley's body changing. It began with his body hair. The thick red coating that for years Riley had proudly adorned on his body began thinning out until it was like it was never there (and in this reality, it wasn't). The freckles that had only barely spotted his face began growing in number until Riley was left with a cute freckled look to go along with his softening jawline and facial features. Memories of Sandra or whoever it was disappeared as did the scars, blemishes and cuts that had been incurred from this fight or that match. All in all, Riley was well on his was to twinkhood and he was starting to enjoying the ride.
Meanwhile, Calvin was at a loss for words. Here was his best friend, who he couldn't deny he kind of had a thing for, fucking his school bully in front of him in the freaking church! Calvin was both hurt and angry to say the least. Sure, Riley had a beautiful cock, Calvin couldn't argue with that, but how could that outweigh years of friendship and experimentation?
Calvin couldn't hold back his feelings any longer. "Tyler, what are ya doing? Why would ya do this to me? And in God's palace? How could you?" he cried.
Between moans, Tyler barely managed to look up at his friend. It was hard to concentrate given how roughly he was being fucked, but in time he managed to process what Calvin meant. It was a good thing it was a fairly easy change, Tyler thought to himself. That way, he could enjoy his first time even more. "Hey! Johnny!" Tyler yelped between thrusts. "I wish -- oh fuck yes -- that Calvin -- FUCK -- liked this show -- fuck yeah GIVE IT TO ME -- and joined in!"
Piecing together what Tyler meant, Johnathan managed to figure out the brunette's wish and add a little extra. Minus the screams of pleasure, Tyler now said, "I wish that Calvin liked this show and joined in WITH RILEY'S CONDITION!"
Calvin's mood immediately changed. Be was already turned on by the sight beside him, but now he was truly enjoying the show. Soon enough, the blond farmer's boy couldn't take it anymore, so he stripped off his blue jockstrap and flung it across the room before kneeling in front of the brunette, who was still moaning uncontrollably, and plugged the twink's mouth with his cock.
In no time, the brunette twink was getting roughly fucked from both ends and all parties involved loved it, now knowing that they were all definitely gay. Of course, that was the just the first of the changes to come.