After five times through the routine, Jennifer decided that Jake's dancing skills weren't a fluke.
She said, "Well, since we've got two more hours until the pep rally, I think we should try and do something with the costume."
Jake nodded and said, "Can we get the blood out?"
Jennifer shook her head. "That would be impossible." But, since you've already got the mask, let's try and do something with your body.
Jennifer froze the video of RJ so she could get a good look of the markings and colors of it. She pulled out a big bag full of makeup, tubes of body paint and some rollers and brushes.
She copied the red and black color scheme of the costume using black as the base and different shades of reds and grays to contour and add muscle definition. Working from the shoulders down she slowly traced and defined, even sometimes enhancing different aspects of his body. She outlined his abs and his pecs making them stand out and she even drew on two large dark nipples. She even painted his fuzzy dick and balls getting creative and adding what looked like thick veins. It was hard for Jake to keep from getting aroused as the brush flicked back and forth over his cock and balls.
Looking at him she said, "Wow. You must be really confident in your body to let me do this. Jake felt at ease. He was going to be great. He had worked out the dancing and had gotten used to walking around naked after a day of doing it. This was just one more thing.
Then, switching the video to a position facing the back, she turned him around and did the same on his back and ass and his legs. She even had him bend over so she could match the inside of his ass with the rest of the color scheme using the same dark pinkish purple she used on the nipples to give him a more horselike hole.
Finally, as a finishing touch she drew what looked like a large brand on his left ass cheek that was shaped like a horseshoe and had the letters "E.H. 4 EVER" inside of it.
She stepped back and looked him over. Then she used black nail polish to darken his fingernails and toenails.
Jennifer did a great job. She stopped to congratulate herself in happy, excited tones. "Wow, it almost looks real!" she said. Then quickly she said, "It is real! Just grow a tail and replace your feet with some hooves and you'll be set."
Jennifer's positivity finally backfired on him. Jake watched as his paint job went from realistic, to movie grade special effects to actual blood and flesh in less than 5 seconds.
He was horrified. He reached up and felt the distended fleshy nipples that adorned his muscles pecs and felt a surge of excitement course through his veins. He reached down and felt the raised skin of a brand in his ass and realized that he had never been that desperate in his life to commemorate his high school experience. Then, he felt something brush over his ass and he turned his ass to the mirror. On first glance, he had a tail and on second glance he realized that his asshole now looked like a deep puckered cavern rather than what he had been working with earlier.
His dick felt more needful than ever. It's pulsing veins broadcasting his elevated heartbeat throughout its length.
He looked down and noticed his feet were no longer get but shiny black hooves.
Resigned to this new look he said nothing. He was broken.
To top it off, Jennifer said, "I gave you a really nice coat."
Instead of just colored skin, everywhere the paint had touched except his nipples and asshole gained a shiny coat of hair. Thankfully, he hadn't had the mask as she had made her comments. He still had his human head and face.
Jennifer washed the paint off of her hands seemingly forgetting that her canvas was now a half-horse half-man creation that she had painted and then bragged into being.
Jake put on the mask before the rest of the team came in and then they went over to the gym to show off their routine.