Jeff stopped for a minute and pondered it. Even in his BO hazed mind, he knew this was an important decision. Whatever he chose, he would be for the rest of his life. All the rank possibilities shuffled through his mind before he chose one; the nastiest one he could think of.
"Anus. I want to be your smelly asshole, Simon", he pleaded with sincere eyes. Simon laughed, "Are you serious, you nasty fuck? You would choose to be my anus? Alright, whatever floats your boat!".
Simon pulled off his wet, smelly jockstrap and it hit the locker room floor with a wet splat. He stood there in all his naked, hung glory. "On your knees!", Simon barked, to which Jeff complied. "So, Jeff, this is a big decision. If you choose this, you will be my asshole for the rest of my natural life. You will breathe farts, feel and taste my shits push through your mouth, and have smelly anus hairs growing out of what is now your lips. Here, take a good look before you decide".
With that, Simon bent over and pulled his very hairy ass cheeks apart. His puckered anus was shown to Jeff. Jeff moaned at what he saw. It was so dirty, and there was so much hair! Because of all the sweat and hair, Simon had a lot of trouble keeping his ass clean. Jeff would always be tasting shit!
Jeff leaned a bit closer, examining the smelly doughnut that would soon be his whole existence. Simon grinned and let loose a huge fart. The warm gas hit Jeff right in the face. He gagged at the putrid smell. It was so terrible. However, his cock, at full mast, had different ideas. Jeff moaned as he came in his pants from the smell. Jeff's degraded mind told him the answer. Yes. He had to be Simon's anus.
Jeff shoved his face right into the hairy mess. The taste and smell was abhorrent. Jeff was extremely turned on,
it felt like he was being pulled in. Everything went dark. He could feel his body getting sucked in, his limbs receding back into himself.
Simon immediately felt that something was off, he felt shit pouring out of his ass. splashing all over the locker room floor. It smelled something fierce. Jeff had to be doing this, he thought to himself. But just as that thought came into his mind another came out, the guys would be back in the locker room any minute if they weren't already in here.
He had come to a stark conclusion. He had to eat it all. One by one Simon started packing the shit into his mouth. It took an hour but He finally got it all in there. Simon could feel the logs swishing around in his now bloated stomach. Jeff had only felt pleasure since he shat out that wide load. Leaving him in a field of lust, and knowing Simon ate his own shit just tripled it causing Simon to feel the lust too. When the lust had reached Simon he had felt the immense need to smear his shit covered fingers all over himself jerking off as he did it. The mixture of cum and shit made the locker room smell amazing.