Charlotte opened her mouth to answer the question, but was caught off guard by something. This old woman looked familiar. And not as though she reminded Charlotte of someone she had seen a while ago, either. No, there was something very recognizable about her.....
“Didn’t I see you at the grocery store today?”, Charlotte asked, intrigued by the seeming coincidence of it all. Elspeth chuckled, amused that this was the girl’s foremost question at the moment. Mortal humans were such simple creatures. “I believe so, yes! I had thought you were familiar yourself,” Elspeth admitted. “But I still need you to answer my question. You’re going to address me as Mistress and remain clotheless now that you’re living here. Is that understood?”
Before Charlotte could respond properly, Elspeth cut her off, her eyes widening along with her smile. “Hold that thought, Dear. Excuse me, but I have someone I’d like you to meet.”
Looking around the room, as Charlotte watched in silent and naked confusion, Elspeth eventually found James on the coffee table, transformed into a teacup. Picking him up and placing him in front of Charlotte, Elspeth ominously spoke about what was to come as she readied another spell.
“If it makes you feel any better,” she began, “you’re not the only human that I have living with me like this. In fact, I have a friend I think you already know that I’d like you to meet in person!” Charlotte has at least several questions aimed at these two short sentences alone, but again was unable to get a word in edgewise as Elspeth continued to talk.
“You MAY be a little cross with him, but please don’t be too mad! I assure you, he had no intention of taking part in what happened between the two of you, even if he seemed to have enjoyed it a great deal!”
As Elspeth chanted in a strange tongue over the supposedly normal teacup, Charlotte’s mind was reeling with confusion and questions that, were she any less strong mentally or emotionally, would have utterly wracked her sanity.
Eventually, Elspeth stopped speaking in this unknown language, and the teacup turned into what Charlie thought was a handsome, cute, and noticeably well-endowed young man who seemed to be the same age as her. He looked embarrassed and horribly nervous, with his penis fully unsheathed from his foreskin as it stood at utmost attention, something that Charlotte found highly flattering and alluring as she stared at it. The young man took notice of this, and sheepishly covered himself up, causing the otherwise bewildered Charlotte to giggle, momentarily having forgotten her predicament.
“Charlie, Dear. This is James. I purchased him from a today from a friend of mine, and he will be your new companion in this house along with Silas, my cat. I wonder where he’s gotten off to..... Nevertheless! I think it’s worth you knowing that James here.....”
Before James could say anything, fully aware of what Elspeth was going to tell this beautiful woman sitting in front of him, the old sorceress revealed everything to her.
“In order to deter James here from leaving this house, I cursed him to turn into any inanimate object when in the line of sight of any other person besides me. I’ve made an exception for you just now, as you can see. I want James to be able to interact properly with his new friend, after all! Now, I had taken James into town to the grocery store, where we first met. After getting him there, I..... misplaced him, as he had turned into an object. As you’ll notice, I was just looking around for him here as if I couldn’t tell where or what he was. And that’s because I couldn’t! You see.....”
And so on and so on it went, Elspeth explaining everything in as much detail as she good to the puzzled Charlotte, as James’s face went redder next redder as the truth came to light. Eventually, Elspeth got to the part about Charlotte’s apartment, as well as the bath she had taken.
As Elspeth finished her tale, Charlotte looked at James, pure crimson in the face and incredibly erect in the groin. “..... is this true?” she asked him. “Did you..... really turn into that loofah I used to..... wash myself with?”
Unable to bring himself to lie and contradict the word of the all-powerful Elspeth standing right besides them, James nodded meekly, covering his bare testicles in preparation for the kick he was certain Charlotte was going to deliver to them.