You're about to grab one of the junior sized condoms, hoping it will turn you back to Scott even if the color is slightly different only to have your phone chime with a text alert.
'See you in 30. -SA'
SA? Oh fuck, in all the confusion you forgot about the secret admirer who sent you the things in the first place, if anyone has an answer it would be her.. or him.. At the moment the thought of a him seemed more exciting, remembering your encounter with Nick causing your dick to swell slightly in your jockstrap.
You grab a set of keys you know goes to your car, tell your brother you're heading out to pick up something you need from the store, and head out to your truck. You know it on sight even if this is the first time you're seeing it. Instead of going to the store you head straight to the park. It's slightly deserted this time of night, except for one figure sitting on the edge of the fountain, in a hoodie so their face is hidden.
Getting closer you see it is definitely a man, a bit on the slender side, especially compared to your current body. "Woof, DILF alert. Honestly, I half expected you to show up as a kid, this is better." You recognize the voice, and when he looks up you recognize the face. Your brother. Not Nick, your current brother, or Mark, Scott's brother, but your original, younger brother, Henry.
"You sent those things?" You're walking towards him as he's standing up and pushing back his hood.
"A gag gift I picked up in a magic shop, I'm surprised they work, too. I've had some fun with shit in that place." He shoves his hands in his pockets as he looks you up and down. "Looking good though, vast improvement."
"Fine, which one will turn me back?"
Henry just grins and starts walking. "One of them will, figuring out which one is part of the fun, you'll just have to try them all on. Or who knows, maybe you'll find one you like and stick with it. I wouldn't mind you staying like this."
You fall into step with your brother as he starts walking down one of the park paths, never minding it's night time. "Why? Just tell me?"
"Consider it payback for all those times you and your asshole friends made my life miserable growing up." Henry's voice is a little bitter, you tried apologizing for that a few times over the years, teenagers are dicks, but apparently not all was forgiven. "Maybe you'll see what it's like to be other people for a bit." He comes to a stop in a part of the park where there's little light, and feels even more secluded than the empty fountain plaza. "Maybe I can make it up to you a little though.."
Henry moves towards you and you instinctively step away, your back bumping up against a tree. Henry's hands move towards your pants fly, quickly undoing them and letting them fall around your ankles. "Jockstrap. Nice choice." But he pulls that down to, letting your long, thick cock flop free. "Oof, no wonder. If you were trying to get back to you, you definitely picked one that was too big." You want to push Henry away, hike up your pants and get out of there, but another part of you wants to see where this goes. It's like being in the bedroom with Nick all over again.
Then Henry 's kneeling in front of you and taking your rapidly hardening cock into his mouth. Finding out he was gay was one of the things you used to tease him about, and now.. well.. you hadn't expected this. You have to admit, he's good with his tongue, he's pulling you to the edge of orgasm and leaving you hanging there, the nerves in your cock practically raw. You dig your fingers into the tree bark as you rock your hips, fucking Henry's mouth eagerly. Finally, you come, and your brother happily laps up ever single drop, letting your damp cock fall free of his lips as he grins up at you.
"I'm not gay.." You pant. Though Henry is getting to his feet with a smile.
"With some of those condoms, you are." Henry winks and starts walking back down the path to the fountain. "Try the extra sensitive ones, those are amazing." He waves back at you and disappears around a bend in the trail. With a sigh, you pull your pants back up and head to the truck.
You make sure to drive by the store one the way home and grab a couple things to cover your story, clean up the condoms off your bed, and hide the box under your bed. You have no more will to mess with those tonight. Sex with two brothers in the same evening.. This was a strange night. You strip down to nothing, you know this is how you sleep as Jay, and roll into bed.