Billie met Jen at school. He was a little nervous because of being humiliated yesterday, but Jen's makeup had covered up the body paint well- at least for now. She stayed with him every moment of the first half of the day. "Don't worry, Billie; I've got this figured out!" she told him.
At lunch, she sat right next to him again. About halfway through the lunch bell, she spotted Joe and Gary swipe the 10 gallon water jug and approach Billie's seat. "Hey Billie!" said Joe. "I don't know how you keep hiding your true identity, but I think if the gym class got to see what you are, then the rest of the school deserves to see as well! As they raised the jug over Billie's head, Jennifer scooted right up to Billie's side. The water poured out of the jug, thoroughly drenching them both. Billie looked down at his arms; the water had washed away the makeup leaving him as a Dalmatian again. The cafeteria roared with laughter. Billie got embarrassed and started to leave.
"Billie wait!" Jen said.
He turned around and looked at her. His jaw dropped, sitting next to him was a sexy pink and white kitty cat. "Whaaaat.... Howwwww?" he stammered.
"It's me! It's Jennifer!" the hot cat said.
It was Jennifer sitting there; she was soaking wet. It appeared that she had been body painted as a cat from head to toe. She had a pink and white painted cat face; her chest, arms, and legs were painted with pink and white fur. "Jen! What happened to you?" Billie exclaimed. "OH NO Jen! Did Dan get you too? Look in a mirror! Somebody turned you into a smoking hot kitty cat!"
"Well first of all, thank you for the complement," she said. "After we figured out that we can't remove the paint, and we can't hide the paint, I walked back to the carnival. I got in the machine, took a deep breath, and set it to turn me into a cat for one year. Then I went home and covered myself up with makeup because I figured they would try to expose you again. I wanted my changes to be revealed with yours so you wouldn't feel so embarrassed and alone when they exposed you again.
Hey, so you think I'm hot huh? Tell me, did you think I was hot before, or is there something about a girl being indefinitely turned into a pink cat that turns you on?"
"You look cute as a cat, but I thought you were hot, I mean cute before. I mean, you make a stylish cat but......" he faded off tripping over his words. "But that's crazy!
Dan forced this transformation on me. I was already stuck as a freak; why would you go and choose to make yourself into a freak too? Wearing face paint to a party is one thing, but having to be seen in body paint for a year makes you look like a freaky weirdo! No one can really see your face when making eye contact; they can only see an animal face! Are you really stuck as a cat for a year?"
"Yes, I am going to be stuck as a kitty for a year. I did it because I love you, Billie! If I can't free you from this embarrassment, I'll go through it with you!" she said. "I know its not easy looking at someone through your own eyes knowing that they can't see your true face, but I'm going through this with you!" she said. "Look at me, Billie. When I first saw you with a dog face, I thought you were one sexy pup. The second you saw me like this, you called me a 'smoking hot kitty cat', but you tried to play it off. Next you told me I looked freaky! I wonder if somewhere deep down, you have a fantasy about you and your crush being turned into animals, and when your fantasy came true, you let it slip that you like seeing me like this. You don't have to answer me now, but take a long look into my eyes, and if you like what you see, come by my house tonight at 7 PM."