Erin had bad memories of her first time. She had hooked up with some guy she met on Tinder when she'd been lonely and kinda depressed in her first year, and he pretty much just got off on her and she never saw him again. But now she'd obviously reverted to a virgin, and Ty was one too, so... why not?
"Do you wanna have sex?" she asked.
Ty's eyes almost popped out of his head as she said it. "Please," he breathed.
Erin giggled at how enthusiastic he was. Teenage boys, huh? She pulled off her oversized clothes and lay down, purring, "Like what you see?"
Ty definitely did. He threw his T-shirt and jeans off, and his boxers soon followed. As he positioned himself and his cock head rubbed along Erin's pussy, both of them were burning up with anticipation.
Erin breathed in slowly as Ty pushed inside her, the boy making sure to be slow and gentle so as not to hurt Erin. Her pussy clung tightly to his shaft to keep his motions limited, too, and she half-expected him to just cum from the pressure. But not only did he hold on, he made a motion to comfort her- he reached up and softly cupped her boobs, brushing her nipples with his thumbs.
Erin moaned loudly at this, and reassured, Ty started to thrust in and out eagerly. Unsurprisingly, both teens were quickly approaching their peaks, and Erin's hips bucked upwards as Ty's thrusted into her, their motions rhythmic and instinctive.
Ty was desperate to hold out for Erin's orgasm, but her tight, wet passage around his inexperienced shaft was too much, and when he realized, "I'm gonna cum bare inside Erin's pussy," any chance of holding back vanished. He hunched over her, thrusting mindlessly like a dog about to mark its territory, and shot more loads of his seed than he could count inside her, not a single drop leaking out.
For her part, Erin, surprised by the feeling of his seed as even before this she'd never had a guy cum inside, came almost instantly. Her body clung to his, his body's instinct to release his semen meeting her body's instinct to take semen inside of it, and she moaned and gasped for air while he grunted with pleasure.
Once they'd come down from the high, Erin kissed Ty messily, and whispered, "That was so good." Ty blushed, and to lighten the romantic tension in the mood, she teased, "I hope you can wish away creampies, 'cause otherwise I'm probably pregnant."