Jimmy silently looked at Brenda for a minute before a smile appeared on his face. “It’s okay if you can’t take off the tail.”
Brenda raised an eyebrow. “But how? I’m a mermaid and you’re a human.”
This prompted Jimmy to chuckle. “Would you mind keeping a secret for the two of us?”
Brenda nodded. “You have my word.”
At the confirmation, Jimmy began taking off his Hawkeye costume and tossing it aside, leaving his underwear as his only piece of clothing. Jimmy closed his eyes, clearly concentrating on something and reciting a few words under whispers. After a few seconds, his whole body shudders and he lets out a sigh.
Brenda looked at Jimmy with a newfound sense of curiosity. “Jimmy… What did you just do?”
Her crush smiled. “I’m about to reveal something only a few people in my life know about, and you’re going to be one of them.”
Jimmy began to walk towards the bed when Brenda spotted a few blue scales appearing on his upper legs. Then his legs began locking together at the heels, causing Jimmy to fall beside the side of the bed next to Brenda with an audible “oomph!”
“Jimmy! Are you alright? Do I need to… oh!” Brenda watched in awe as Jimmy’s legs pressed into each other, the little blue scales appeared one by one, slowly at first, then picking up in pace as they swept over his entire lower body.
The merging of his legs proceeded to move up and up until the transformation shredded Jimmy’s underwear, briefly revealing his penis before it became covered up and protected by layers of scales.
Brenda watches as the changes finish up with his feet flattening out into light blue tailfins.
The mermaid was awed by Jimmy’s change. Her eyes admired the way Jimmy’s dark blue scales shimmered, glittering in the room’s light like little sapphires. The scales entirely consumed Jimmy’s lower body until it ended in a V-shaped border between his upper and lower half.
“Jimmy…” Brenda said, almost speechless. “You’re… you’re…”
“A merman.” Jimmy said with a chuckle. He swishes his tail around, now having full control of his fishy limb.
Brenda looked at Jimmy’s tail, her eyes still wide in shock before a new feeling of admiration began to wash over her. “I can’t believe it. My crush was a merman all along.”
“Yup,” Jimmy said before taking Brenda’s hand and giving it a loving kiss. “My mom’s a mermaid and my dad’s a merman. What about you?”
Immediately, Brenda began to snap back to the reality of her situation. “Oh, crap! My parents! They’re human! Oh, man! How am I going to tell them about this?”
At that, Jimmy began gently stroking Brenda’s cheek. “It’s all going to be alright. My parents can help you, I promise.”
“You mean it?”
“I mean it. I’m always here to help a fellow mer. Now let’s just enjoy the night, together. You and me.”
Soon enough, Jimmy’s tail began to wrap around Brenda’s. His muscular scaly limb having a firm hold on Brenda’s relatively slim lower half. The way Jimmy’s scales rubbed against her own gave a weird feeling of pleasure she never felt before.
Admittedly, she was still nervous about how she’s going to deal with being a mermaid but knowing that she wasn’t alone and that her lifelong crush was a handsome man of the sea seemed to give her a newfound sense of security.
Mer or not, she loved Jimmy dearly and was willing to be by his side, from that night and beyond. It was also that same love that had her smiling when she felt Jimmy’s tail humping against her fishy groin.