Dustin felt bad about taking advantage of Ty, but he couldn't resist, he'd always wanted a Cat.
And now he even had one that can talk! He just needed to make sure that Ty altered reality enough so that he could keep him.
"You know Ty, if you dislike it that much, then why don't you use a wish?
You could say something like 'i wish that i was treated like Dustin's best friend, despite legally being his pet'."
Ty glared at him "You know what? You're right, i'm sick of you slipping up and everyone else treating me like a regular pet,
even though i can talk! I wish that i was treated like Dustin's best friend, despite legally being his pet. There, happy?
And you know what? I wish that everyone in town would treat me like a VIP! I wish that you have to feed me,
pet me and scratch me behind the ears whenever i want! And i wish for you to turn into a Cat whenever i want and for people to treat you like MY pet whenever you're a Cat! Now you're gonna see what it's like!"
Dustin thought that he'd managed to trick Ty again when he made his first wish, but didn't expect Ty to get that upset.
"Come on Ty, you know i didn't mean it like that!" Ty just turned his head away. "Hmph!"
"Don't be like that. I mean you ARE technically my pet." Ty turned toward him again with an upset look on his face.
"Alright, that was the last time! For that you're going...