Among the three condoms you hold one stands out for, well, not standing out. No wonder you never really noticed it in the box. The wrapper was plain white with no markings or bright colors. Tearing it open, the condom itself is just plain and clear. Simple. Basic. Was it really that simple?
Placing the other two condoms on top of your clothing you roll the one in your hand onto your cock. It fits like a glove. Wrapping your hand around it, you begin to jerk off. You can feel your cock shrinking in your hand even as the condom stays a perfect fit. This has to be it. You close your eyes and lose yourself in the moment. You can feel yourself shrinking all around, which is no surprise as Jay is a huge guy compared to your real self.
Something feels off as you finally cum into the condom, but you open your eyes, eager to meet your old reflection... only to see Scott's face staring back at you. You were the kid again!
"God damn it!" You shout, your high pitched voice cracking. You quickly get dressed and storm out into the apartment where your brother is sitting on his couch, pants on thankfully. Though he looks confused when he sees you.
"Um.." Henry starts but you cut him off.
"What's the big idea?! That wasn't even the one that turns me into Scott! I used those up!" Without thinking you throw the other two condoms at him.
Henry picks up the two and looks between them. "You used the clear one.. in the white packaging?" He suddenly sounds very worried.
"Yes." You walk over to your brother and put out your hand. "I'm done with the games, give me the right one now."
"I did. You used it." Henry says, looking at the other two in his hand. "That one always returns you to normal, I have a whole box of that type for when I mess around." He gets up and walks into his bedroom, returning a moment later with a whole box of just that one style. "I don't get it, it always works." He sits down and fishes out a pamphlet from the box and starts reading it over.
You cross your arms and glare at him, which used to work when you were the older, bigger brother, but you figure right now you just look like a petulant child. After a moment his face turns white. He starts reading, his voice shaking a little. "To alter which form the basic condom returns you to, spend five uninterrupted days in that form. I... umm..."
You feel your face heat up. "You mean like I just did, because you wanted me to fuck around as a kid for a week?!"
"Sorry, I.."
"You didn't think. You just decided to fuck around with my life!"
"Maybe the one that turned you into Scott will now turn you back. I probably have some in my box. Or we can find another of these that gives you a body you like. I'm.. I'm sorry, I didn't know.. I just wanted..."
You reel back and punch Henry square across the jaw, shaking your hand and biting back tears. "You fucking dick."
"Okay.. I deserve that. We can figure this out though." Henry puts the box of condoms on the table. "Rest, you're probably all spent now but in a few hours we can put our heads together and try to think of something. I'll get my stash, you can even go back to Jay, I got another of those.."
You stare at your brother, deciding..