Jake walked into the bathroom with Sam, just in case some extra muscle was needed to hold Colton down. The two were immediately surprised to see Colton sitting on the floor, his head in his hands. A whimpering sound could be heard faintly escaping his lips.
Sam slowly turned his head towards Jake. "Is he... crying?"
Jake chuckled. "Hey Colton, get up, you baby!"
Colton looked up at the two gay lovers and immediately stood up, flailing into the wall. "Get away from me faggots!" He said, unable to keep his composure.
"If I had a dollar for every time he said faggot..." Sam muttered.
"Its okay babe, he'll be one soon enough." Jake reassured his boyfriend.
Colton's voice was frantic as he stared at the two jocks before him, visibly afraid. "What do you gays want? I-I'll do anything. I have money. I can give you money. Just don't rape me!"
"Relax, dude. We're not here to rape you." Jake said, although he not-so-secretly wished he could be fucking Colton right now. "I just came to collect my payment... so to speak."
"P-payment, what, what are you talking about?"
"Jeez for a strong and powerful football captain, you sure are a scared little guy."
"You-"
"But that's besides the point." Jake said, rubbing his eyes. "Remember a few minutes ago when I asked you Transform or Dare? Well, sixty seconds went by, and you didn't pick. So... now you get both."
Colton looked confusedly at Jake, finally starting to regain his composure. "Pfft. We both know that shit isn't real."
"Oh really now?" Sam replied.
Colton scoffed. "Wow. I can't believe I let a couple of fucking fags intimidate me. Over this stupid shit? And to think I bribed you with money so you wouldn't abuse me."
At that point, Colton started to make his way towards the bathroom exit. "I'm going to call my parents. Consider yourselves expelled, you disgusting faggots."
Jake and Sam each grabbed Kevin with an arm and pinned him against the wall. "Not so fast, Captain. I haven't even told you what your Transform or Dare is going to be." Said Jake.
It was all Colton could do to fight the two stronger men off of him. "What are you doing?! Let me go! You can't do this! Help me! Somebody he-"
Sam placed his free hand over Colton's mouth, shutting him up.
"Listen, Colton." Jake said. "We're not here to hurt you... or fuck you for that matter, but the longer you struggle, the more difficult things will be for you. Just listen to what I have to say, and then you can go and cry your little heart out to mommy and daddy."
Colton relaxed, glaring fiercely at Jake. Sam took his hand away from Colton's mouth, Colton returning the favor by spitting in Jake's face. That was enough to set Jake off, as he came hard, his dick falling through his pant leg and onto the floor.
"Oh... fucking hell." Jake moaned.
Sam picked Jake's dick up off the floor, pointing it straight at Colton.
For once, Colton stood there in silence as this unfolded, too horrified to speak.
"Now Colton." Jake said. "If I wanted to, I could have Sam stick that cock straight into your mouth right now, and you'd be gay for a week. But that's not what I'm here for. Since you didn't answer my Transform or Dare, you get both. Don't worry, I'll be quick."
"For your dare, I want you to move out of your parents' house on your own. I know the football team will be counting on you tonight, so you will also be quitting the team."
Colton jutted in. "You cant- this isn't-"
"Hey, I'm not finished yet. For your Transform, late tonight, when the full moon is high in the sky, you will transform permanently into a gay man. Your environment will start to change, and you will be very confused and uncomfortable until you try fuck your girlfriend inadvertently transforming her into a gay man, which will complete your transformation."
Words spoken, Jake let go of Colton. Colton could only stand in terrible disbelief, before bolting out of the bathroom.
"Well, I would say that went well." said Sam.
"Indeed it did." said Jake. "He's in for the ride of his life. Now, what do you say we finish up?" Jake said, looking at his hard cock, throbbing for attention in his boyfriends' hands.
The two lovers rushed into a stall, locking the door behind them as they furiously got to work.