“I think we should play safe and take the long way around the lake,” suggested Kayla, “There’s nothing really along that path besides an old swimming hole, but odds are, no one should be there right about now.”
Alyssa took a deep breath and responded, “Alright, I’m trusting you on this one... but you better be right about no one being at the swimming hole.”
“Well, if we hurry along, we should be fine.” Replied Kayla, starting down the narrow, dirt path.
The two girls walked along at a brisk pace, trying to keep quiet, which wasn’t exactly easy with their large horse halves and the brush along the trail, and trying to get off the trail before running into someone.
“What do you think would happen if we’re seen?” Asked Alyssa, her ears on full alert.
“I don’t really know,” replied Kayla, “obviously they would probably freak out, since we’re centaurs and centaurs are just myths, but it’s not like we’re doing anything wrong... we haven’t hurt anyone, or anything...” Kayla paused, rethinking that last part, “I mean, I didn’t intend to hurt Warrior... it wasn’t my fault... I don’t know what happened... and you were willing... you wanted to play with me and be bred by me...”
Alyssa listened tentatively, “I wanted to help you out, seeing your horse half in need of sexual release... I didn’t exactly want to lose my body for this... I was a show jumper, one of the best around... and now I’m-“
Kayla came to an abrupt haunt, quickly reaching over and cupping Alyssa’s mouth. “Do you hear that?” She asked. The two girls’ ears stood tall as they listened. The sound of two people could be faintly heard, screaming, playing, carrying on.
“Someone’s at the swimming hole.” Whispered Kayla.
“God darn it, Kayla! I was trusting-“ Alyssa started before being interrupted with a ‘shhhh!’ from Kayla.
“Look, we probably shouldn’t go back. I still think our best bet is to just sneak by the swimming hole to the best of our abilities, and if we think we’ve been seen, we just book it. No one will catch us.” Kayla quietly explained to Alyssa.
“And they’re making such a racket down there now, they probably won’t even notice us.” Added Alyssa.
“Exactly. Now let’s get a move on.” Commanded Kayla, starting down the trail again.
The two centaurs walked at a slower pace, making sure to stay clear of any sticks or stones that may make extra and unnecessary sound. They stayed in the centaur of the path, trying to keep their large lowers away from the brush that would make sound.
Suddenly Kayla’s ears went back and her nose went up. She sniffed violently into the air.
“Horses.” She said to Alyssa in a whisper. “Smell ‘em?”
Alyssa took a deep sniff. “Yeah.”
“Be extra careful and extra quiet... we really can’t be seen now...” Kayla whispered.
If the two girls still had toes, they’d be tiptoeing at this point. For such big and unfamiliar bodies, they were, however, keeping extremely stealthy and quiet. The horse smell got stronger and stronger as the two centaurs approached the swimming hole. As they rounded a big, dead maple tree, the horses came into sight. A beautiful Palomino and Haflinger stood tacked up, tied to a birch tree.
Kayla took another smell of the cool air. “Geldings.” She commented.
“They’re so beautiful... and sexy...” Alyssa added with a whisper.
“Yeah, they are... but we really need to keep going.” Kayla said, trying to keep her eyes off the horses by looking at Alyssa. A dull thud was heard. Kayla looked down to see Alyssa’s cock rock hard and smacking against her horse stomach.
“Alyssa! What are you doing?! We need to keep going!!!” Kayla scolded her, grabbing Alyssa’s shoulder and shaking her human half violently in an attempt to snap her out of it.
“But KayKay... they’re far enough away from the water and hidden behind enough bushes! Just a quickie?!” Begged Alyssa, her cock slapping against her belly again.
Kayla looked up at the horses again. The palomino flicked its tail just right, showing off its plump anus. Kayla felt her cock beginning to stir and slip out of its sheath. An argument pursued in her head over whether or not to take a moment and relieve some stress or straighten up and keep moving. ‘Plap. Plap.’ Her cock wouldn’t stop slapping her furry lower belly. It won.
“God darn it... fine. But be quick and VERY quiet,” Whispered Kayla, “but I call the Palomino.”
Alyssa sighed, “Fine. The Haflinger’s ass looks fatter and juicer anyways.”
The girls giggled for a moment before realizing again where they were and the situation they were in. Again, they slowly crept onwards, but this time, they had a different goal.
The two centaur gals reached the horses. They were in the exact right spot to be hidden from the two apparent girls in the swimming hole. Kayla placed a hand on the Palomino’s hind end and rubbed it.
“Hey... doesn’t this look like Nugget, Sarah’s horse?” Asked Kayla.
“Yeah... and this looks like Lillian’s horse, Apache.” Noticed Alyssa.
“Screw it. I’m so horny right now, I don’t care who’s horses these are.” Kayla said with a devious smirk.
“Amen to that~” added Alyssa, as the two girls proceeded to mount the geldings.
The two horses grunted and pinned their ears back as the centaurs mounted them. Their tight, virgin assholes tightly gripped the girls’ cocks.
“Damn!” Kayla quietly moaned, “Nugget’s ass is tight!”
“You’re telling me! Apache is squeezing me for all it’s worth!”
The grunting and huffing of the fucking was being drowned out by the two riders splashing and carrying on in the water. The fun didn’t last all that long for Kayla and Alyssa, however. The tight geldings brought them to climax rather quickly.
“Oh here it comes! Here it comes!” Moaned Alyssa, on the verge of cumming.
“Shhh! Keep qu-iiiiiiet!” Silently moaned Kayla, as her cock pumped a much larger than usual load into the Palomino’s ass. Alyssa burst, as well, also over filling the Haflinger’s ass.
The two girls waited a moment for their raging horse erections to simmer down before dismounting the geldings. Both horses’ assholes spewed out horse spunk like Yellowstone geysers, spraying both Alyssa and Kayla with their own seed. Kayla’s right mind finally returned.
“Alright Alyssa, we’ve had our fun, now let’s get out of here!” Whispered Kayla as she tugged on her friends arm.
“Wait, look!” Alyssa said in a loud whisper, pointing at the horse’s rears.
Kayla and Alyssa watched as each geldings’ crotches swelled and bulged. Like magic, the two horses both grew their testicles back, each set falling neatly into their soft, leathery scrotums. And in the same manner that happened to both Kayla and Alyssa, overly sized mare pussies came to life underneath Apache’s and Nugget’s gaping, cum covered assholes, leaving both horses now as hermaphrodites.
“It works on them, too...” said a wide-eyed Kayla, staring at the two brand new pussies and ballsacks.
“I guess so!” Replied Alyssa in an excited whisper.
Kayla finally broke her transfixed stare and motioned to Alyssa, “Alright, we really need to go. Now.”
The two centaurs went back to sneaking their way down the trail, and just in time, too. Lillian and Sarah waded back to shore to dry off and retrieve their clothes.
“This sure is a great spot!” Exclaimed Sarah, “nice and secluded! No pervs around to spy on us!”
“I know! Kayla from the barn showed me this place last summer! It’s perfect for taking a quick skinny dip while riding!” Replied Lillian with a smile.