“You liike me, you like my new boody,” Lyle taunted Alex in a sing-song voice, while Alex was still balls deep.
“You better not tell Gregg about this, or else,” threatened Alex.
“Or else what? You won’t fuck my straight guy pussy anymore?” Asked Lyle.
“For starters, yes,” Alex kissed Lyle again before exiting his big ass.
The two of them showered, ate breakfast, and got ready to go over to Gregg and Penelope’s house to try to sort things out. Lyle dressed his new body in sweatpants and a t-shirt, but the underwear choice Gregg would have never approved of, (a pair of tighty whities that he filled out every cubic inch of with his shapely ass and nice big package, thanks only to his big balls and not his two inch flaccid penis).
When they arrived, Gregg was sleeping on the couch in Lyle’s smaller body. “Hold up, this’ll be a fun way to wake him up,” said Lyle. He pulled down his sweatpants and rubbed his underwear bulge on Greggs face.
Gregg shot up, saying, “Jesus! What the fuck?!”
“Haha, you should see the look on your face,” Lyle told him, “It’s your own junk, anyway.”
“Sadly that’s the most action I’ve seen since we’ve switched,” Gregg admitted, “Penelope won’t go near me in this body. She’s too freaked out. Hey wait you guys, did you have sex with my body at all?”
Lyle kept his promise and didn’t say anything, but Alex thought that since they were asked directly, they should tell the truth.
“Yes, we did. Just once. We figured this might be permanent so we’re trying to get used to it. Please don’t be mad,” requested Alex.
“Oh no, why would I be mad? My body fucked my own little brother after being fondled to death yesterday by his boyfriend..” said Gregg, annoyed.
“Well technically, your little brother fucked your body,” Lyle chimed in.
“What?! My body is manly, it’s not meant to be fucked like some little bitch!” Exclaimed Gregg, “I’ve never even put a finger up there! I can’t believe my own wife won’t sleep with me but my little brother and his boyfriend are off fucking my body without a care. We’re finding a way to switch back today.”
“I’m all for trying to switch you two back, but please don’t be mad at us for simply continuing to live,” said Alex, who had become more brazen.
When Penelope got up, the four of them tried everything they could. They talked to customer service, just to get the same threat as yesterday. They went looking on beta tester forums to see if anyone else had had the same problem, but nothing. As far as they could tell, this was an anomaly, and there was really no way to report this to the police, or to sue, without proof of who the two men originally were.
They even went back into the game, but every time they logged out, no matter what variable they changed, Gregg was assigned to Lyle’s body, and vice versa.