Luke was beginning to realize something about his friend as he flopped back on the bed staring up at Dave in his brother's body. Dave was definitely into guys. Sure he should have realized it when he gave in to having sex with him in his own body, but with Lyle's muscular form looming over him it became insanely clear. Luke was normally straight, sure he may have thought about a guy once or twice, who didn't? But mostly they just weren't his thing. But as Dave he had no problems.
So if Dave was still raring to go in Lyle's body, did that mean Lyle was..?
The line of thought cut off as he felt a couple of fingers sliding into his ass. He gasped, but that was cut off with a forceful kiss. Part of him wanted to tell Dave to stop, to let him turn back into himself. Another part of him that he wasn't sure was really his ached for this. Dave's mouth continued to explore his body, down his neck, a little suck on each of his nipples, as those fingers kept loosening him up.
Soon, he felt that pre-slicked cock, sliding into him, longer if not quite as thick as the one Dave had as himself. He moaned as it pushed against something inside of him that sent waves of pleasure shuddering through him. He wrapped his arms around Dave, enjoying the feeling of those muscles shifting against him as he thrust in and out.
Just at that moment there was a knock on the bedroom door. The person on the other side didn't even wait for an answer before coming in. "Luke, have you seen my ha..." The words died on Lyle's tongue as he saw the sight on the bed. His brother's best friend being fucked by... himself? "What the hell?"
Dave sprang off Luke, sitting on the edge of the bed with his hands in the air, a little bit of an 'I surrender' look on his face. Luke gasped and pulled a sheet over himself. "We can explain!" Dave started.
Lyle was looking between them, but his eyes kept lingering on his own naked body sitting in front of him. Dave started stammering. "We found an amulet, if you touch a piece of clothing while wearing it it turns you into the person it belongs to." Dave's eyes flicked to the hat on the dresser, with the amulet below it.
Lyle looked incredulous, but there was only so much argument you could give when looking at your copy. "So you turned into me to fuck Dave?"
Dave winced. "Actually I'm Dave, that's Luke." Dave said as he motioned to Luke in his old body. "I was trying to turn into Luke, I didn't know the hat was yours and then one thing led to another.."
"I should kick both your... " Lyle started.
Luke quickly interrupted. "You're gay, aren't you?" That stopped Lyle short, looking worried. "You have to be, otherwise Dave here wouldn't have been so.. into it." He looked over at Dave a bit apologetically. "Sorry, I figured it out from being you. I'm not usually into guys but in your body.." He felt himself heat a little.
Dave laughed, then shrugged. "Well.. at least I know why I was even more into it as Lyle here." The bother looked back at the real Lyle who was reaching behind him to close the door.
"Fine. But you still owe me for using my body like that. And I have just the way you can pay me back." Lyle's look changed from worried to excited. "And you two might even enjoy it." He looked at his own naked body watching him then at Dave and pursed his lips. "I'll wait down stairs... Don't be too long."
"Or..." Dave started with a look to Luke. "You could join in."
Luke didn't hate that that thought made him excited.