Making their way inside their motel room, Danielle looked at the time on her phone. "3:35 a.m."
Both of them emotionally and physically spent, Danielle and Andrew passed out on their king sized bed.
-----
Several hours later, Andrew felt the sunlight hitting his face. "Oof, that was weird" Andrew said groggily. He looked at the alarm clock besides the bed. "1:22 p.m."
Danielle sat at the foot of the bed. "I don't feel like going out right now." she murmured. Andrew was inclined to agree. As he got up, a thought occurred to him. He walked over to Danielle and put his hands on her shoulders. "Maybe today is the day we..."
"I was thinking the same thing," Danielle said with a smile. "Why don't we do it right now?" Andrew asked. "Yeah, before we get cold feet" Danielle replied.
Danielle pulled her top off. Andrew quickly undressed, and took a quick glance in the mirror. Danielle unclasped her bra, and tentatively took off her skirts and panties. She decided to lay down on the bed, unsure of what else she should do. Andrew nervously climbed on the top of the bed. He looked down at her and saw excitement but uneasiness as well. Nonetheless, he felt the need to push forward. Danielle felt this big, physical presence on top of her but when she looked into Andrew's eyes, it seemed as if he wanted to be anywhere else.
"Come on baby, fuck me" Danielle blurted out.
"Yeah, I'm about to give it to you." Andrew responded. As he heaved up, he could feel all his nerves fraying at once. His eyes darted all over as he was about to penetrate. Danielle started to feel panic and felt herself move to the left of the bed ever so slightly.
Andrew couldn't go through with it. He moved off of Danielle and sat at the edge of the bed, his hands covering his face. Danielle sat motionless on the bed.
"I'm sorry Dani...this just didn't feel right." Andrew solemnly said. "Not like this."
"I was about to kick you off of me." Danielle admitted. "I was petrified."
Andrew sighed. "I liked the idea of doing this, and I love you with all my heart but...I'm not attracted to you like this."
Danielle lit up. "Thank god you said that. I get that this is my secret desire or whatever, but it doesn't work for you."
"I look like John Cena mainlined HGH everyday."
"I look like Kate Upton injected herself with helium."
They both started laughing hysterically. Andrew decided to lie down next to Danielle on the bed. Caressing her face, Andrew smiled. "I love you exactly as you are. You don't have to change for me." Danielle smiled back. "Andy, you're perfect to me." The couple shared a long, deep kiss. As they did so, magic started shimmering over them. They suddenly felt themselves changing. Andrew felt himself getting...smaller? Danielle became very confused as she could feel the bed getting bigger. In a moment, it was over. Andrew and Danielle walked over to the mirror and found themselves to be back to their original teen bodies.
"Hi Dani"
"Hi Andy"
They briefly hugged before quickly realizing that they were both, in fact, naked. They both went to pick up a piece of clothing, before looking into each other's eyes. They knew this was the time.
Danielle pulled Andrew onto the bed. "WAIT" she shouted. She picked up a condom from the desk and handed it to Andrew. Andrew quickly put it on and once again found himself on top of Danielle. Andrew looked down and saw the girl he loved. Danielle looked up and saw the boy he loved. With the slightest hesitation, Andrew brought his body down and started sweating as he felt his penis penetrate Danielle. Danielle, having only imagined what this would be like, grabbed the bed with one hand and Andrew's back with the other. Andrew felt himself getting more confident with each thrust. Sweat was pouring down Danielle's body as she felt more, and more excited.
"Oh, Andy, oh, oh, oh, oh"
"Yes, yes, yes, yes"
"Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, OOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHH"
Danielle reached climax and let go. Andrew felt his penis and testicles become covered in cum. Both physically exhausted, the young couple laid down on the bed. Andrew and Danielle looked at each other wistfully.
"That was...cool" Danielle said,
"Yeah" Andrew said.
"I love you Andrew,"
"I love you, Danielle, "
--------
After quick showers, Danielle and Andrew got dressed. They thought about going to the local diner for their first meal post coitus. As they walked towards door, they noticed two potions on the counter and a note.
Danielle picked up the note and started reading.
"Congratulations! You overcame your base, animal desires and found a real connection. Please enjoy the rest of your Valentine's Day...unless you wanted to try something else. If you're curious, these potions will allow you to see each other in very different lights for the rest of the day."
Danielle and Andrew paused and looked at each other.