Seeing as nobody wanted to buy the contestant and how he was strolling around on his brand new hooves she figured that she might as well use him as advertising for her shows. There is nothing fascinating about a horse strolling around, however, people are interested when they realise that that horse used to be a human. In thinking this madame Illusia set out to turn him just enough into a horse (she decided) so that he would still be recognized as a human.
She looked at him who was strolling on the stage placing one hoof in front of the other, something which he'll be doing an awful lot of in the future. And said I have decided! You will spend the rest of your days walking on what you wished to have, hooves, however I will not turn you into a complete animal.
As she said that she got close to him and started to rub his torso which looked like that of an animal with his shoulder blades under him. She gave him a nice coat of grey fur and she also started elongating his neck so that it would match the dimensions of a average size horse. She also rubbed his ears which started elongating and becoming pointy while moving at the top of his head.
She started to stretch his face out just a little bit while also flaring his nose however his face still resembled that of a human, although stretched with animal features. She also opened his mouth and squeezed some of his teeth as they started changing shape to molars which could munch on grass and hay. She did this with his back teeth while leaving the rest relatively unchanged just for shape. His mouth was now made for an entirely different purpose while being somewhat concealed.
Madame was proud of her work and said while letting go of his teeth:
You see, now you can still be recognized as a former human and somewhat converse with them of your experiences with having these hooves which you admire so much.
He was happy while at the same time trying to say something.
Oh don't worry it'll come in time. But for now go enjoy what an animal feels on a daily basis.
He couldn't talk just yet however he was so excited about his predicament that he couldn't conceal it anymore and he started to get aroused.
Madame noticed this and smiled. I see that you really enjoy what has happened to you.
He nodded.
Madame Illusia got an ideea as she got close to him again.
She started carressinghis member while his ears perked up. He started looking at her while getting mere and more aroused.
He started to lift his left front hoof up out of instinct to relieve himself, however it was far out of reach and his new keratin hooves would retain the same shape for the rest of his life not allowing any movement. At some point she just stopped leaving him really aroused.
He started looking at her confused.
Well, part of an animal's life is to deal with its problems. So I guess you'll be finishing that on your own.
He of course tried however it was to no avail, he simply wasn't up to it.
Well, you must have imagined that you couldn't jack off with hooves so you knew what you wanted.
OK, this one is one me but the next time you better find a way with those hooves of yours.
As she said that she placed a spell on him that would make him ejaculated every time he got horny over not having fingers.
As she did this he started getting horny again confirming her suspicions that he actively wanted this. In minutes of constant numbness in his fingers and swaying his member between he's legs he came and splattered his load on the stage while looking up at the ceeling.
Go what are you waiting for, go advertise she said as he's job would be to walk on four legs through people at the carnival to showcase madame's powers.