while you were waiting for your drinks you remembered an important detail and became suspicious of Selina's 'lesbian' story, so you said "I came here hoping to know why you rejected me and I trusted you, but I didn't expect you to tell me such a lie."
"But I didn't lie, I'm really not interested in men, it's girls I like." Selina said
"No, you are not a lesbian and there are two things that make that very clear to me. The first is that you invited me over here on what appears to be a date, if you were just to stop talking about your sexual preference you could have just whispered in my ear and I would understand. And the second and most important fact is that I know you've turned down even girls who have attempted something more than simple friendship, some of whom I know are actually lesbians, making the same excuse that they weren't your type." you said
Selina froze, from her reaction it was clear that she was shocked to have been denied and had no way of counter-arguing.
"You better tell him the truth Selina. Sometimes a human appears who finds out about us. No need to worry about the consequences, you know we can erase his memory later." the waitress said intruding on the conversation
"No Emma, you know I'm against it." Selina said to the waitress
"What are you talking about? Are you referring to me as 'human'? and what is this story about erasing my memory?" you asked
"It's because I'm not human. I am what you humans would call a monster. Emma isn't human either." Selina said
You were a little surprised by the revelation, and Emma invited you and Selina to a VIP spot in the diner where no one would bother you.
"Here no one will see or hear you, so you can talk without worry." Emma said and then addressed you with "What happens to you next will depend on your actions. If I see that you could put us in danger, I won't hesitate to make you drink the amnesia potion." said goodbye and went back to the counter.
"No need to be afraid, she has relatives who were discovered and had a bad experience. Humans are generally afraid of us, so we disguise ourselves as humans in order to survive." Selina said
"This makes sense, as most of the time creatures are talked about they are portrayed as evil." you said
"I'm glad you understand. So we can still be friends. You're a good guy and I even like you, but we're not even the same species." Selina said
"Despite the shock I still want something more intimate between us. Can't you date humans?" you said
"No problem for me, but I don't know if you'll still be interested, especially after you see me in my true form." Selina said
"Speaking of which, what are you?" you asked
"I am....."