Eboni glanced from you to Natalie and then looked ruefully down at her own penis. She fondled the perpetually exposed dickhead. "Jeez, guys! You two make having a foreskin look like so much fun. Why don't I get a foreskin to play with?!"
"Uh, because you chose a cut cock?" Natalie volunteered.
"Well, I've changed my mind!" Eboni declared. "How do I switch cocks?"
"Don't ask me," you said. "I only just joined."
Natalie thought about it, pumping her own foreskin up and down her glans as she pondered. "Hmmm... you could always give yourself a second dick in addition to the one on your crotch. You know what Nikki did with her cocks."
Eboni rolled her eyes. "What Nikki does with her cocks is her own business. I, for one, want to be a futanari, not a freak show exhibit."
"Just a suggestion," said Natalie, still playing with her foreskin. "You could always talk to Michelle again."
"The club president?" you asked.
"Yeah," said Natalie. "She helped Eboni swap over from that Japanese cock she originally had. I bet she could do it ag... agai... againnn... OH! OH! OHHHHH!!!" Natalie's cock suddenly began shooting cum at her face like a geyser. "Heh, that's what I get for stroking myself while I'm thinking."
"Look, Natalie," Eboni sighed. "I've already asked Michelle to help me replace one dick. It'd be so embarrassing to beg her to do it again. And it was so much hassle for both of us the first time. Do I really have to go through with that again?"
Natalie rolled her eyes as she wiped cum from her face and dick with a tissue paper. "Do you want a foreskin or not, Eboni?"
"Yes," said Ebony. "Yes, I really, really do!"
"Then you'll have to tell me how you plan to get one, Eboni," Natalie said, sounding much sterner than a naked girl wiping jizz from her cock had any right to be. "You only have so many options."