After some consideration, he decided he would... Make it so those cool girls would ALL date him, know it and be perfectly fine with it. After all, why limit himself to just one, if he could have all of them?
Naturally, while after his wish they would all be heads over heels for him, and perfectly fine with his performance in bed, they won’t openly be his personal harem. No, instead they would simply let peoples speculate. As a result, there was some bets around school over which girl he was dating, most peoples thinking the other girls were tolerating Ty so they wouldn’t have to exclude whoever he was dating from their group. Although, some were thinking he was just their gay friend. (Not that he have any problem with that, since he already monopolise the most popular (& cute) girls of the school as his girlfriends thanks to his wish. And said girlfriends don’t care either, to be honest.)