The mystery girl had pale skin, a freckled nose, blue eyes, and wavy shoulder-length dark brown hair, and she wore a cheerleader uniform. She glared hatefully at Hailey.
"Diana?!" Hailey gasped. "You did this?!"
"You can't prove it, Hail," Diana shrugged. "All you saw was me watching the madness. It was entertaining, I admit, but you can't prove I caused it."
"Oh, come on!" Eboni snarled. "Who the fuck ELSE could've done it?!"
"Could you get that fucking dick of yours off my leg?!" Diana snapped, blushing as she felt Eboni's bulge pressing against her thigh.
"Wait, who is this?" you asked.
"Diana Greenfield, my ex-girlfriend," Hailey explained. "We were dating last year, but I dumped her after I caught her dating another girl behind my back."
"You sure had some nerve, Hail!" Diana thundered. "Breaking up with me for that after all that sex YOU had with the other girls in your stupid club!"
"Hey, I told you that I was polyamorous and I'd be having casual sex with other girls!" Hailey shot back. "YOU had a full-on relationship with that other girl, and you didn't tell me about her!"
"Sounds messy," you said, awkwardly running a hand through your curly black hair.
"It was," said Hailey, "and it looks like it just got a little messier. Isn't that right, Di?"
"Tell the truth," Natalie added, narrowing her eyes at Diana.
"Fine," Diana scoffed. "There's nothing you can do to stop me anyway. I'm still pissed about you fucking those animal-people and dumping me, Hailey. So mad, in fact, that I decided to pay you back by destroying your little club. With a little help from my wonderful squad captain Haylee, I found a way to do just that!"
"Is it just me, Hail, or do you have the same name as the cheer squad captain?" you asked.
"No way, Ruby!" Hailey said. "Her name is H-A-Y-L-E-E. My name's H-A-I-L-E-Y. Totally different! But that's beside the point." She turned back to Diana. "So, how'd you and Haylee turn us human?"