"What about Charlotte?" you asked. "She may not have even gotten a dick yet."
"Yeah," Natalie nodded. "Diana and Haylee barely know her, and they certainly don't know that she's joining the Futanari Club."
"Smart plan," said Hailey. "So, where is this girl?"
"Uhhh... in the dick storage room, getting her dick installed," Eboni said.
"Then let's hurry!" Hailey said. "We need to catch her before she goes through with it!"
The four of you raced off to the dick storage room. Once there, you searched through it for Charlotte. Before long, you found Charlotte watching as a hirsute hippie girl knelt over Sarah. The hippie was peeling back Sarah's (now rather tight-looking) foreskin to inspect the glans underneath.
"Your tip looks fine, Sarah," said the hippie girl. "I told you that tearing was just you popping your dick cherry. You can get back to fucking Lottie once it stops smarting."
"What a relief!" said Sarah. The Jewish girl then noticed you approaching and waved. "Welcome back, girls! We've been busy while you were gone. As you can see, I found a way to grow my bush back out, and check out what I did to my foreskin!" She let the tight, phimotic skin shroud snap back over her tip where it puckered snugly. "Now more baggy skin for this girl! Oh, this is Phoebe, but you can call her Pheebs, or even Granola or Woodstock."
"Oh, I know who Granola is," Hailey laughed. "She's friends with half the Anthro Club."
"And you are?" Sarah asked.
"Name's Hailey," said Hailey. "Hail for short, if you like. Oh and before you ask, I'm not Haylee Irons. That bitch is named H-A-Y-L-E-E Irons. I'm H-A-I-L-E-Y Forrest. I did date her friend Diana for a while, though."
"Isn't that the girl from the Genderswap Club who used to be a guy named Dylan Greenfield?" asked Sarah.
"That's right," said Hailey.
"Did she ever seal her swap?" asked Sarah.
"Not that I'm aware of," asked Hailey.
"Why the hell not?" asked Sarah. "She seems to love being a girl."
"She likes theoretically having the power to swap back and forth, even if she doesn't use it," said Hailey. "Being trapped in a male body for so long's given her a complex over bodily autonomy."
"Nice to see you again, Hail," said Phoebe. "So, what brings you to the Futanari Club?" Phoebe's eyes widened as she realized something. "And why are you human again? Last time I checked, you were an anthro tiger."
Hailey sighed sadly. "Remember how I said Di and I used to date? Well, we didn't part on good terms. Di especially was so pissed with me that she teamed up with Haylee to... do something to the Anthro Club. I have know idea how they made it happen, but the anthros are turning back into humans one by one, and our magic can't turn them back."
"Oh no!" Phoebe gasped sympathetically.
"And it gets worse, Woodstock," Eboni added. "Haylee apparently hates the Futanari Club, so she's coming for our dicks next! We gotta stop her before that happens."
"Wow, this is serious!" gasped Phoebe.
"It is," you said. "We need to act fast. Where's Michelle?"
"At the Mermaid Club," Phoebe answered. "They ordered a shipment of dicks, so she went to deliver them with a new recruit named Melanie."
"We'll just have to start the mission without her," sighed Eboni. "'Chelle can get involved later."
"What can we do?" Phoebe asked nervously.
"We need a spy," you explained. "It has to be someone without a dick whose face none of the cheerleaders will recognize."
"Or at least one they won't connect with the Anthro or Futanari Clubs," added Natalie.
"That's why we want Charlotte to join Cheer Squad and feed us information," said Hailey. "Seeing how she hasn't installed her dick yet and she hasn't been hanging out with you dickgirls long enough for Haylee to know about it."
"But..." Charlotte gasped. "But that means... I won't be able to put on my dick for ages! I've been looking forward to it all freaking day!"
"Nobody's gonna force you, Lottie," you said. "I can always go instead. If I get my cock removed, I'll turn white. That should be enough of a disguise to fool the cheerleaders. So, which of us goes?"