Patrick asked, "I didn't know there were different kinds of pet to choose from."
Jeb said, "Well, dog is definitely the most popular choice followed by pony and then pig. It all depends on how you want your pet to behave, what kind of obedience protocols you will expect from him. For example, if you want him to be a fish then you better have a pool that you expect him to swim in all day. Fish isn't a popular choice but it can be fun knowing you have a naked fish boy waiting for you in the pool."
Frank asked, "How about a pony. Then he can carry us or pull us in a cart."
Jeb said, "Excellent choice. What about the other two registrations? You want them all to say pony."
Patrick asked, "Can we leave them blank for now? We might change our mind before we need them."
Jeb said, "Alright but let's be honest boys. I've seen enough of you boys posing as pets to try and get girls to recognize what you're up to. When it's your turn, you better have decided because it will look suspicious filling out registration papers in front of the police. Your papers should be filled out and ready to go before you take off your pants."
Frank, Nolan and Patrick all tried to deny it but Jeb's facial expression made it clear he wasn't buying it.
Nolan said, "Well can I at least decide what kind of pet I want to be since I'm the one doing the dare?"
Jeb swatted Nolan on the ass, "Ponies are supposed to make pony sounds like neighin' and snortin'. It's too late to change your mind. I already wrote pony on your papers."
Nolan got scared, "You're going to expect something from us to keep our secret."
Jeb said, "You're darn tootin. Your a virgin pony and that needs to be fixed. You need to learn your place so that you behave right as a pony. Now I don't expect you to take my large dick your first time so let's have your two friends prime your hole and prepare you for my big dick. And you better start neighin' and snortin' or I'll use the tawse on you."
Jeb turned to the other boys, "I'll give you a free tawse if you'll use it to help train your friend to behave like a pony."
Jeb held up a tawse and Frank reached out for it.
Patrick asked Frank, "You're not going to tawse your friend Nolan are you?"
Frank said, "Of course I am. It's part of the deal."
Patrick said, "Alright but remember that you'll get yours when it's your turn."
Frank said, "Alright but I'm not gay. I'm not going to fuck my friend."
Nolan wasn't sure if he was happy or disappointed. Either way, he sighed.
Jeb said, "You better. He really needs a good fucking to get him into his role as a pony. He's still not neighin' or snortin'."
Nolan said, "Please don't. I'm not gay."
But Jeb grabbed Nolan and held him tight. Frank lined up his dick with his friends hole. "I suppose a hole is a hole as long as it's not mine. Sorry Nolan but just think of the girls your taking it for."
Nol' screamed as Frank plunged in. He didn't want them to know that he was secretly enjoying this.