The thief didn´t let Ryan wait for long. After mustering him from all sides, he ended up in front of him again. Seeing the size difference between him and Ryan, the thief of Johnny´s body knew what he wanted to do. He summoned some of the grey water, which had still been by Ryan´s feet towards himself, resulting in his naked body becoming stone as well. While Johnny had an idea why the former gargoyle did so, Ryan had none.
One thing Ryan noticed instantly. While he was immobile, could not get his body moving even an inch with all his muscles, the thief could easily move while being stone. The now stone-Johnny grinned up towards Ryan as he enabled their changes.
It took Ryan a few seconds to realize that the fake Johnny was growing bigger, but he did not realize that he himself was shrinking along. In a minute or two the two had switched size, or the former gargoyle gained even a few inches more from Ryan. Only for him to tease Ryan´s new size. “Now you´re not the “big” brother anymore, huh?”
With another evil grin, he tipped against Ryan´s head, forcing him to look up to him. “Get a good view, little boy” he said next, before slowly pushing the head back down, so Ryan was forced to see all the thief´s now stronger body. It hadn´t been only his size that the gargoyle took for himself, but also his strong muscles.
To Johnny, who had been forced to watch, it had been terrifying. His once big brother now looked even scrawnier than he had before, while the former gargoyle, who had stolen his body, now looked bigger and beefier than Ryan had before. At least Ryan looked still human.
Ryan´s head stopped being pushed down when his field of view reached his own cock and balls, which looked rather out of place now. It hadn´t shrunken with him. The reason was the torture the gargoyle had planned for the older teens to witness. As Ryan could now see his treasure down there, shrinking it would be far funnier for him, and more horror to Ryan himself.
While he didn´t need physical contact to change a body made of stone, it was far better to do so in this moment. The big Johnny placed the fingertip of his right thumb on Ryan´s cock, and slowly pushed it inwards. At the same time, just at the edge of Ryan´s field of view, he slowly pulled his own cock forward with his left hand.
Ryan was indeed horrified seeing his cock give way, shrinking shorter and smaller with the pressure that thief put on the tip. His once proud twelve inches were reduced to a fourth, a mere little three inches, when the thief finally stopped pushing.
At the same time, what had been Johnny´s cock of four inches was by now thirteen inches long, and much to Johnny´s own horror, it looked good on the thief´s version of his body in big.
After the cock was resized, the thief laughed and grabbed Ryan´s balls, squeezing them smaller as well. They soon fitted to the little cock Ryan had, now mere marbles instead of golf balls. The thief´s own balls, former Johnny´s, now had that size instead, maybe even a little more.
Satisfied with his own adjustments, the former gargoyle willed the stone-liquid to flow away, back into a puddle at Ryan´s feet, leaving a human looking like Johnny, but in Ryan´s old size, standing before the former Johnny and Ryan.
“I must say I like this body. Maybe I won´t need to rob anything from your friends. I can just let it go into nothing if I want to, after all.” Laughed the only being of flesh in the area. He even used the now kid-sized Ryan to lean on while laughing. He thought about spending the cum he had inside his now meatier balls, but decided against it. He still had three targets to collect, and he didn´t want to be surprised by them. And he still had to change Ryan´s form, after all.
Johnny was crying for his poor brother´s fate, while Ryan himself was pleading to himself to wake up from this nightmare, but he couldn´t.
The thief lifted Ryan´s old clothes and slowly dressed in them. Being a bit bigger than Ryan before made them look stretched, but at least he wore something. It had been good to get Ryan out here, but the other´s wouldn´t run after a naked, unknown teen. Maybe if he was a girl, but he wasn´t.
“As you two were family before, I will be so good to leave you as the same creature. But the size will remain that way, little boy.” He said after he finished to tie the shoes. And with that, Ryan´s changes started again.
The water incased his stone feet and climbed up his body, changing everything on its way. Ryan´s feet gained short little claws on his reduced toes, having them merged down from five to three like Johnny´s had before. His thin legs got a bit more mass back, but were still a far cry from there former power.
Ryan´s balls were pushed into hiding, while his little prick of a cock grew hard and stiff, even worse than being simply stone, standing out under him. A tail grew out above his ass, easily as long as his body was height now.
Above the tail, on Ryan´s back, wings started to form, if not as big as Johnny´s had become in relation to his size. While Johnny might be able to lift of with them if he wasn´t stone, Ryan would not be able to, still being too heavy for them to work.
His stomach showed a little rounder than normal, giving his new form some baby fat still. His chest wasn´t to muscular, more likely continuing the little pudgy figure Ryan now had. His arms were short and weak, ending in his little hands tipped off with cute little claws.
Ryan´s head vanished into a ball of water, making him panic inside. Would he be blind and deaf forever? But like his brother before him, it was only a stage to finish his head´s new form. A small muzzle with a little less sharp teeth than Johnny had now, bigger eyes and ears formed under the water, while his hair was washed away. Little stubs grew out on top of his head, the base of a set of horns that would never grow bigger as Ryan would remain a kid-sized gargoyle for eternity. The final movement of the water pushed his muzzle slightly open, making Ryan drink the stone-liquid.
Ryan now was a gargoyle, just like his younger brother Johnny, but he was tiny compared to his brother now.
“While you are a young gargoyle, you also won´t look that fearful at others. Man up, little guy. Now, stand before your brother on the pedestal, strike a more menacing pose, even if it will look playful on such a tiny thing like you, and face forward with an angry growl on your lips.” The thief of their bodies ordered Ryan around, and much to the shrunken teen´s horror, he followed that order, leaving him in the shadow of his once little brother. Now they looked more like father and son to the environment.
When the teen-sized Johnny was satisfied with the overall outlook of the two, he left them to look for the other´s. “See you around. Have fun standing guard.”
And both Ryan and Johnny could do nothing else but wait, and hope that the other´s wouldn´t end up with them here.