Before Ty could suggest or wish for anything, he heard Eileen say, "Ty?"
"Yeah?" he replied.
"I think I wanna stay a man," Eileen panted in his deep voice. "For now, at least. Do you mind using your power to make it so no one will notice?"
"Sure!" Ty smiled, kissing the DILF in front of him and wishing no one would remember the woman he'd been.
Sure enough, history altered so that Eileen had been a man named Emilio his whole life, his wardrobe filled with men's clothes, his memories changed so he'd always been a man (though he remembered her old life) and he became Becca's father rather than her mother. Emilio's life seemed very satisfying to him, and he appreciatively kissed Ty, who kissed him back happily.
"How's that suit you?" the teenage boy asked.
"Pretty good," Emilio replied. "Now, can I pay you back by fucking you up again?"
"Sure, but I have an idea for a wish first..." Ty said.