Your decision is reached quickly.
"I wish to be immortal and young forever."
"As you wish," says the genie calmly.
For you, it is a perfectly logical wish to do. A smart thing to ask for, really. You have the sort of hot body that makes any male envious and every girl happy to gaze at you and even more to be in bed with you. However, you know that beauty does not last forever. It fades, inevitably. Sooner or later, you'd get wrinkled and old and have grey hair. But with this wish, you could get out of this awful fate that awaited everyone. And the contrary, you'll be like that forever! It was the perfect wish! You could then use the last wish to be rich forever as well! All your problems would be solved thanks to this genie. A great new life was right in front of you!
"Are you ready?" asks the genie.
"Yes, yes! Go ahead!" you say, bursting with excitement.
"Here's your wish!" she says while the magic shoots from her fingers and hits you.
Little did you know that she was playing a dirty trick on you. After all, you never asked to be immortal AND keep the super body you were now blessed with...