“What?” She said, normally.
“Did you just talk out of your ass?”
“Yeah, what about it?” She looked perplexed.
“Isn’t that a little weird? Shouldn’t you be talking with your mouth”
“I can’t talk with my mouth, duh. I know it’s unusual but I was born this way.”
“Hmm, interesting. You mind fixing something to eat I’m starving.”
“Sure, why not.”
Amanda heads to the kitchen, she decides to fix peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. You watch, seeing everything is normal. But then she accidentally gets some on her hands, and instead of washing it or licking it off, she pulls down her skirt and panties and inserts her finger into her anus, clearly enjoying the taste, despite the fact her anus shouldn’t have any tastebuds at all. She pours some chips onto each plate and picks up the sandwiches, her finger which had just been inside her anus touching the edge of yours. You thank her awkwardly as you go to take a bite of your sandwich, and watch in awe as she begins to tear off bits of sandwich, shoving each “bite” into her asshole. She takes a fistful of chips and shoves the whole thing up inside, wincing as the sharp edges poke her insides. You watch as she flexes her ass muscles to “chew” her food, making movements with her hips to try and “swallow” it, grunting and gasping as she does so. “What, never seen a girl eat before? Weirdo.”