Nate waited until midnight because the site was true to its name, it didn't come back up until a day had gone by after you made a change. Finally right at midnight he was able to bring the site back up. Sam still hadn't gotten back, he was probably hanging out with his new gym buddies, getting beers. Nate clicked under the looks section and then clicked handsome and he saw that there were a number of options. He could do rugged handsome, cute handsome. Finally he chose model handsome and clicked save and unaware. Then he went and watched TV again and fell asleep on the couch.
Around two in the morning he heard a key in the lock and some giggling. He watched as a startlingly handsome version of Sam walked into the room with a busty blonde girl. They were both obviously drunk and making out, the girl all over Sam's muscle.
Sam looked at Nate in surprise. "Sorry man! I didn't mean to wake you up. We're just going in my room." He winked at Nate, flexed an arm and led the girl into his room.