"Forget it," said Alex. "I'm sure you're using your super powers or whatever so you won't blink."
He'd had to unbutton his shirt and pull down his pants, and now he looked in disbelief at the large pinkish protrusion that was now attached just below his navel, protruding out into four long nipples until it curved back inward just above his penis. The man asked, "Aw, you're willing to go through the rest of your life with that?"
Alex looked up and replied defiantly, "If I went on with this stupid game, I'm sure you'd just make things even worse. Besides, I know about plastic surgery. I'm sure a doctor can get this thing off me."
The man grinned. "Well, it's magic, so it'll grow back pretty quickly. But I gotta say, you've caught on a lot faster than most of the other humans I've dealt with. Tell you what -- just drink a little bit more of the milk, and I promise, the udder will go away and you'll only have human parts. Okay?"
Alex's eyes narrowed. "You seriously think I'm going to trust you?"
"Hey, I haven't lied to you, just omitted a detail or two," pointed out the man. "This is your only chance -- you'll be 100% human if you drink the milk."
Alex tried to decide which was the better option -- to live as a freak with a cow's udder, or to trust the man who'd given him the udder in the first place.