Reveling in the afterglow, Joe finally looks over at Amanda. Her chestnut hide looks so sleek and glossy, her tulip ears swiveling toward him intently. As he watches, her auburn tail swishes happily, fanning a burst of pheremones at him from her mare sex. He whickers lovingly to her, then begins to think.
Something is wrong, but he cant quite put his hoof on it... HOOF?!
He looks at his own body, covered in black hair like felt or velvet, slick with sweat. His thick fingers trace the muzzle on his face, even as he feels them stiffening with a horn covering. As he watches, he sees Amanda's changes progressing as well. He suddenly thought "Waitaminute! I said LIKE wild horses! Did that count as a wish?"
Unless he did something fast, they would be horses, maybe even in mind. What did mustangs wish for? Would it even still work for an animal? What worried him was the strange thought of "Maybe he should wait and find out, him and his mare."
He looked around at the horrorstruck students watching him. Oh yeah, fucking in the open does draw a croud, DUH!
Quickly, he considered what to do. Become human? Then again, the half animal form looked cute. And what about the school croud?