"This is going to sound stupid." Cathy blushed. "But for my entire life I always wanted to be more than just a big ugly farm animal. I wanted... to be more exotic."
"That doesn't sound stupid." I reassured her. "I guess if you're a horse every day for your entire life you'd get bored with it."
"Exactly!" Cathy smiled, hugging me closer. "Which is why... I... I want you to make me another kind of animal! Can... can you even do that?"
"Well, certainly!" I smiled. "I took you from your original body to this anthro unicorn body. Like I said, anything you want."
"Wow!" Cathy giggled, clearly excited by the possibilities. "Can... can you make me a... a..."