Amanda told them the story of earlier in the day. She told them about how I had a magic ring and every other detail up until the time Katie came home.
When she was finished, Katie looked at me. The look on her face frightened me. I was afraid she was going to kill me or something. Thinking fast I quickly wished that none of them would be mad if I told them the truth about everything.
The look on Katie's face changed to one of seeking information. "Did you wish for us to have a threesome and then foursome?"
I admitted it. "Well you and Amanda were coming on to each other! I didn't know what to make of it. I figured it was going that way, so I just wished it would happen. And then when Cara came in, I wished that she wouldn't freak out, and would like to join us."
Cara spoke up. "I was pretty shocked when I saw you three," she remembered. "But it wasn't because you were all naked, it's because Katie promised me that she'd wait for me."
I shook my head. "That's because I wished that to happen. Otherwise you probably would have run out of here screaming."
A look of fear developed over Amanda's face. "Joe, did you change anything else. Because I don't remember having tits this big!"
Hoping that my wish would keep her under control, I swallowed and said, "Yes I altered your looks. And your sexual maturity. That's why Katie thought you were a slut."
They all sat there for a minute, absorbing everything I said. Finally Katie spoke up, "Well I think we all had fun. What's the big deal?" Cara nodded her head in agreement.
Amanda still seemed worried. I never meant to hurt her, of course. I think I loved her after all. Up until today, I thought she did, too. I nervously waited to hear what she thought. A thought crept over her face. "Joe, can you do anything with that ring?"
I said, "From what I've seen so far, I guess."
She crawled over to me, her bountiful breasts hanging down seductively. She curled up next to me and said, "Joe, I love you. I love this look. But I want you to do me a favor, and use your ring for it."
Not sure what she had in mind, I swallowed deeply.