The girls decide that there is only one loose end to deal with left, and that's Kyle and his knowledge of how this all started. They devise a nice little plan to make sure that hes taken care of, but given that this is actually a blessing for both of them, want to take it 'easy'. A few days pass after the changes and they get a milker to help with Jennifer's new assets, Jennifer generates 3 different jugs of milk with different properties for the plot to get revenge on Kyle.
The first jug turns Susan back into a human form, but she looks different than she did when she was human, her new form has large EE breasts, blonde hair and legs that don't end. She uses a fake name, Tiffany and heads over to Kyle's house to seduce him into going on a date with her. She rings the doorbell and he answers, "Hello, My name is Tiffany and i'm new to the neighborhood, I'm looking for some company and someone to show me around." she says in her most sweet voice. Kyle immediately gets a hard-on and agrees to show her around town, followed by a movie.
Later that night, after seeing a romantic chick flick that Tiffany forced him to sit through, they head back to Kyle's house, whose mother is out for the night, drinking no doubt. They go inside and sit on the couch, Tiffany makes sure the front door gets left open due to it being a nice warm night out. They put on a another romantic movie and begin to make out, after a few minutes they are both very sweaty from the hot night. Tiffany says "I could use a drink, I have these 2 bottles over in my purse, want to drink one with me?" Kyle is willing to do just about anything to get in her pants and says "Of course I'll have some of your milk babe." Chuckling at his own lame move, he opens the milk bottle and starts drinking it, noting how rich it is, he says "Wow this is thick, I can barely drink it." Tiffany says in reply, "Well, if you drink all of it before I finish mine, I'll suck your dick" Kyle needing no more motivation sucks it all down in 30 seconds. He wipes his mouth clean and then his stomach starts to tingle as the bottle from Jennifer's breasts begins to work its magic. His arms and legs seem to get sucked into his body and as hes writhing in pain from the change, his mouth seals up, leaving him unable to talk. "Well" Tiffany says "You win the drinking contest so its only fair I do what I said I'd do" She pulls down his pants and starts going to town on his dick. As she does, the milk she drank goes into effect, causing her to shift into her natural form. Kyles eyes go wide as he realizes who she is. "And here I thought this might not work!" Jennifer laughs as she walks in to see Susan going to town on him. "Guess what Kyle, its time for you to pick, Transform or Dare!" Kyle not having any mouth and getting fellatio from a large bulltaur can't do anything but moan. "Time is up, you're getting both it looks like." Says Susan as she finishes him off, spurting cum into her throat. "I hope you enjoyed your last male orgasm."
Jennifer smirks and begins to tell him what hes going to transform into, "You are going to transform into a 15 year old catgirl. You are going to be 4 feet tall standing up and comfortable on all four legs as you are on two legs, your front paws will still have opposable thumbs, but your feet will be very catlike in appearance, you are going to have a beautiful coat of white fur with black spots, and your face will have a cute little muzzle with a full set of cat teeth. You will be able to have kittens, and will go into heat whenever I desire you to mate with something, any seed that you accept while you are in heat will produce kittens or catgirls, depending on how much seed you take into you in a day. You will be unable to make more than meows and purring noises but will be fully able to understand everything you do now as far as language is concerned. Your parents will never know you exist and any one who sees you will accept you for what you are." With that being said Kyle's eyes went wide with fear as he felt the changes start. Jennifer continues with the dare, "Next, I dare you to become my catgirl daughter, you will view me as your mother and Susan as your father, you will never cross us, doing everything we ask and enjoying everything a catgirl would do. You will never age thanks to my milk and you will never be able to survive in the world without us. You will not remember your previous life as Kyle, and your new name will simply be 'Kitty'."
Kitty finishes changing into her new body as Jennifer finishes her long dare. Kitty looks up at her mother and purrs happily, and all 3 of them leave the house and head back to Jennifer's house to prepare for the next stage in her life.