They said their rather awkward good byes and Jared went home. As soon as he was gone Rachel hurried to her room and ate white chocolate clits until hers was back to its normal size, a little nub no larger than the eraser at the end of a pencil.
When her mom got home they ate dinner together during which Rachel remained silent. Her mother started to ask her what was wrong, but one look was enough to kill that conversation. Afterwards Rachel went to her room and glared at the box of chocolates. She would have thrown it out, but after all the damage she had done she couldn't just yet, not until she had brought Jared back to normal. Even if he didn't notice or feel that there was anything wrong with him, she wasn't about to leave him stuck. First thing tomorrow she was going to call him, have him come over and then confess what she had done. He could fix himself and then whatever happened would happen. After what she had done to him she was sure that he would want to break up with her, but she deserved it.
Feeling terrible about what she had done she fell into a restless sleep.
A buzzing woke her up in the morning and she fumbled for her alarm clock, only to realize that the buzzing was her cell phone vibrating. She had a call, form Jared no less. Certain that he was calling to break up with her she answered the phone with a sense of doom.
"Hi Jared."
"I'm so sorry," he gushed, "Your clit's still all swollen isn't it? And it's all my fault. I'm so sorry I called."
"What? No. My clit's fine," of all the things she was expecting, that wasn't it. Anyway it's my - "
Before she could say anything more Jared cut her off, "That's great! I was so afraid that you'd hate me for what I did you your big, sexy clit. Anyway, now I feel like a jerk for calling you so early. I probably woke you up, didn't I?"
"It's fine," Rachel reassured, feeling dizzy from relief, "We can talk if you want."
"Ooh, that would be great. I had the craziest dream last night and that's why I was calling you. I was so worried about what I'd done to you, which was probably why I had the dream, but you're not going to believe it. You're probably going to think it's disgusting, but I need to talk about it just to get it out of my system."
"Tell me about it," Rachel urged, unable to help but laugh at the way Jared was talking just like a gossipy girl.
"I dreamed that we were having sex and eating chocolates like yesterday and I was sucking your clit. Everytime you came it got bigger and bigger. It was so hot. When it was so big I could hardly fit it in my mouth you pulled out and I could see that it wasn't a clit anymore, it was a big throbbing cock. That was when I woke up. I felt so disgusted with myself too. I mean it was so hot, me sucking your cock, but then I thought about how upset you were about me sucking your clit so hard it swelled up," Jared said in a rush, "Please forgive me."
"No, no, it's fine," Rachel laughed, realizing now that she had misconstrued what Jared had said yesterday. Now that things were cleared up all remorse was gone and new, wild ideas occurred to her, partially inspired by what Jared had just said, "I'm sorry if I scared you with how I sounded when I picked up the phone. I'd try to explain, but maybe it would be better if you came over and saw for yourself. It's nothing bad. Actually, I think you'll be thrilled."
"Sounds great! I can be over in an hour. I just need to have breakfast."
"Same here," Rachel replied, "An hour will be perfect."
As soon as she hung up Rachel got out the box of chocolates. She was going to have breakfast, but first she wanted to take care of what she was going to show Jared. It was something she wanted to give herself time to get used to.
Three white chocolate clits and her clit was gone, leaving nothing but a smooth expanse above her pussy lips. Looking through the box she then located a dark chocolate penis, no balls, and ate it. There was an almost painful tingle and in the space where her clit had been a swelling appeared, rapidly growing to surpass the size of the clit which it was replacing. The tingling began to diminish, going from painful to pleasurable as the growth slowed then stopped when the nub reached an inch long, the skin covering it slightly wrinkled.
Rachel gently ran a finger along it, smiling as it began to swell, the wrinkles smoothing out as the foreskin retracted to reveal the head of her new penis. It felt so good, better than stroking her clit, but as much as she wanted to pleasure herself, she couldn't. Or at least not yet she couldn't. Another dark chocolate penis brought it to the size that her clit had been yesterday. It was absurdly small of course, no larger than her thumb, but it was still a penis, and a quite well formed one at that in Rachel's opinion. Of course if anyone had told her yesterday that she would be pleased about growing a penis she would have thought them crazy. Now though her only thought was what the look on her boyfriend's face would be when he saw it.
Getting dressed proved interesting to say the least. Her new penis, despite its small size, was far more than any pair of panties was meant to contain and it took some adjusting to get it to sit comfortably, and even then there was a visible bulge in the front. To make matters the sight of that lump excited her, causing the bulge to grow as she got an erection.
Oh how she wanted to stroke herself through the silky fabric of her panties, but she forced herself to stay focused.
Picking out a pair of pants also took some work since she didn't want to wear something so baggy that it looked bad, but she also found that her tighter pairs of jeans were painful to wear, the crotch seam and zipper working together to press down in a most uncomfortable way on her penis.
In the end she settled for a slightly loose fitting pair of jeans, had a quick breakfast of toast and waited for Jared to arrive.
He showed up half an hour late and flashed her an apologetic smile, "Sorry about that. My mom was late getting started this morning so I ended up having to make my little sister breakfast and walking her to the school bus. It would have been fine, but she wanted pancakes and after she got on the bus I had to go clean up the kitchen. I didn't want to leave a mess for my mom, you know?"
"Of course that's fine," Rachel was shocked that Jared had gone as far to cook and then clean up afterwards since in all the time she had known him he had never shown any interest in cooking, nor had he been overly concerned about cleaning.
"Yeah, I figured it's time I started doing more around the house. Besides, making pancakes was kind of fun. I'm considering making breakfast from now on, just to help out a bit more around the house," he smiled and shrugged, "So, what did you want to show me?"
"We'd better go to my room," there was really no reason for it since her mother had left for work before she had gotten up, but it felt right to do it that way.
"Okay," Jared followed her, "Everything's okay, right?"
"Oh yeah," she reassured, "I was worried until you called me and told me what you did. Now everything's fine. Really, I think you're going to love this."
In her room she turned to face Jared and unzipped her jeans.
Immediately his eyes fell on the bulge in her panties.
"I-I thought you said the swelling was gone!" there was a mixture of fear and hope in his voice.
"Well, it has, sort of," Rachel pulled down her panties and let her new penis hang free, "Take a look and see for yourself."
Jared leaned in for a closer look, "It's...different. Really hot though. The bulge it makes in your panties is really hot."
"Go on, touch it," Rachel encouraged, noting for the first time that she could see the small mounds of Jared's budding breasts through his shirt.
Hesitantly he reached out and ran a finger down its length, gasping when it twitched and began to stiffen and grow, "Your clit...it's just like a..."
The timing was perfect, for at that moment the head of her penis was revealed as her foreskin was pulled back by her growing erection.
Jared gasped and pulled his hand back.
Worried that she had misread the situation on the phone earlier, Rachel took a step back, "Do you think it's disgusting?"
"Not at all," Jared giggled nervously, "That is just about the hottest thing I've ever seen."
Relieved, Rachel found it in herself to tease him a bit, "So does this mean you're gay? That if this hadn't happened to me you'd dump me for some guy?"
"No, it's nothing like that," Jared said quickly, defensively, "Until this morning I never thought about how hot it was to suck a nice, hard cock. Hell, yesterday was the first time I realized that I had a thing for big clits."
"Do you want to suck me off?" Rachel purred, encouraged by the way Jared's nipples were perked up and visible pressing against his shirt, "Tell me what you want."
Jared dropped to his knees, "I want to suck that cock of yours until you come."
Rachel laughed, "What are you waiting for then?"
That was all he needed. Wrapping his lips around the base of her shaft he began to suck and rub his tongue all up and down her length. Rachel shuddered and bucked her hips.
"That feels so good," she panted, juices starting to flow from her pussy, "You want to lay down so we can sixty-nine?"
Jared shrugged, not stopping in his sucking and licking.
"Come on, I feel like I'm neglecting you," Rachel was getting curious about how far Jared's sexuality had changed, she wanted to know what he found hot, other than having his nipples played with, "What do you want to do other than suck me off?"
Jared took his mouth from her cock, but brought up a hand to continue to pleasuring her, "I don't know, maybe you could play with my breasts afterwards and then we could cuddle?"
Rachel missed his use of the word 'breasts', but she did pick up on a hint of embarrassment in his voice, "Come on, if you're willing to suck my cock I can be willing to do whatever you want."
He blushed and looked away, but never stopped with the wonderful handjob he was giving her, "I want to feel you inside me, but I don't know..."
There was only one thing that could mean, "You want me to fuck you up the ass?"
Tears welled up in his eyes as he nodded, "I know it's weird, but more than anything I want to be fucked."
"After yesterday I do owe it to you, besides, that way I can play with your tits as we fuck," Rachel couldn't believe what she was saying, but it felt so good to have that sort of power, to have her boyfriend practically begging for her cock.
Nearly shaking with excitement Jared stripped down, revealing his half hard cock, then dropped to his hands and knees to present his ass to her. Rachel took off her clothing as well, letting her b-cup breasts bounce free.
"I'll try to take it easy," Rachel offered, kneeling down and not sure of what else to say and not sure if she could make good on that promise. As horny as she was, she had a feeling that she'd be going all out if it felt good, but at the same time her cock was under three inches long so she doubted that there was much harm she could do.
"I'm ready," Jared panted.
"Okay..." unsure, Rachel fumbled for a moment, feeling her cock head press against the pucker of Jared's waiting asshole. Taking a deep breath she pressed a bit harder and felt the clenched ring of muscle begin to part ever so slightly, "Here I go."
She pressed as hard as she could and went in as far as she could, which was probably no more than an inch, just enough to get in and feel the ring of muscle clamp down tight on her cock.
Jared squealed, "Oh! Yes! Like that. Oh hell yes I want to be fucked!"
"I don't think I can do any more, my cock isn't big enough for me to really thrust," she said, being honest, but knowing that if they were ever going to repeat this she was going to use another couple dark chocolate penises to increase her size, "But I will play with your tits."
"Yes! Yes, do that!" Jared gasped and squirmed, grinding his ass against her.
Happy to oblige, Rachel leaned forward, pressing her breasts against his back and reached out to begin to tweak and play with his nipples.
New to having a cock, there was only so much Rachel could take before a pressure began to build at the base of her cock. It grew until she thought the was going to explode, then an orgasm wracked her body, her penis jerking and throbbing in Jared's ass while her pussy clenched.
Thoroughly spent, Rachel slipped free, her cock rapidly softening.
"That was so good," Jared slumped down, rubbing gently at his chest,"Oh crap! That's so disgusting!"
"What's wrong?" worry cut through Rachel's exhaustion.
"I came all over myself," Jared groaned.
"No biggie, just go to the bathroom and wash up. I'm going to lay down for a bit and then do the same myself," once again at ease with the strange changes she was making to herself and her boyfriend, Rachel went over to her bed and lay down.