Troy looked at your foot. A toe was curling up.
"Dang, looks like you need more paste, bro," Troy said unzipping his trousers and pulling out his cock and jacking off on to your flattened foot. Carefully, he uses his cum to paste down your toe.
You remember pledge week is next week. Your eyes wouldn't widen if they could. Muffled sounds emanate from your glued lips.
Troy laughs, "Looks like you just figured out what you are!"
Every year, the frat brothers jack off into a towel - a super cum rag. Then the pledges have to share that towel all week, with the frat bros replenishing the cum as often as they can.