The spectacle went on for a long while, both men coming repeatedly. Finally Ty chuckled and released his wish. "Now wasn't that fun?" he said to them.
Jon and Chad quickly backed away from one another in horror, then stared at Ty, trying futilely to hide their still hard dicks. "What the fuck, kid!" Chad shouted. "How are you making us do this disgusting gay shit! This is fucking gross and unnatural." Jon glared: "I always knew this kid had some perverted thing for me, and now he's using some magic tricks or mind control shit. You're lucky we don't call the cops!"
Ty and Dustin chuckled. "You think being gay is perverted and unnatural?" Dustin said. "Not very tolerant," Ty said, shaking his head. "Are you telling me you've never watched lesbian porn?" "That's different," Chad replied scornfully. "It's hot watching two women eating each other's pussies. Not disgusting like men buttfucking." "Interesting," said Ty. "So you wouldn't mind some good old-fashioned pussy-eating..." He made a wish, and suddenly Chad and Jon felt something strange happening to their crotches. "Oh shit!" cried Jon. "Our dicks!!" Ty and Dustin watched as both men's penises slowly shrunk back into their bodies, leaving only a smooth patch at their crotch. Then suddenly that smooth patch opened to reveal an ever-widening fissure. "Are--are you--" stuttered Chad. Ty didn't need to answer; Chad and Jon were now hairy, muscled, naked men with vaginas.
"No! No!" Jon cried. "I thought you were into pussy-eating action," Ty laughed. "Let's see some now!" The men's eyes widened, but already they were moving toward one another. Swiftly, Jon lay down on his back in the grass; Chad lay down atop him, pussy to Jon's mouth, mouth to Jon's pussy, and they began 69ed right there on the lawn. They both very quickly climaxed, then raised their heads to breathe for a moment. "Why are we doing this?!"moaned Chad, before catching his breath and going back in for seconds. "This is your new life," Ty said. "You're a couple now. All the pussy you can eat, forever." He made another wish, making Jon and Chad irresistibly and permanently attracted to one another despite their continuing revulsion at homosexuality. He set them free from their public fucking, but changed reality; as far as the world knew, it was normal that they would be permanently naked with pussies, even if it was still strange and horrifying to them. They would live together in the house where Jon used to live with his girlfriend, who was now free to live her own life away from him, and they would be all over each other any chance they could get.
For the next few days, Dustin and Ty delighted in spying on Chad and Jon as they fucked against the window, not even noticing or caring that they were being so obvious, or leaving the house to go to work, clearly humiliated at having to walk around naked showing off their pussies to the world. "This will never get old, Ty!" grinned Dustin.