Todd confessed, explaining that he had found a wishing ring, and made a bad wish.
"Bad wish? You turned us into freaks! "spat Brooke angrily.
"Just wish us back to normal, "cried Toni.
Nicki looked a little disappointed. She had secretly always wanted to be bigger with more muscle, and she enjoyed her new look. "I think I'm fine with how I look. In fact, I think I want a little bit more." She said as she approached Todd with an open palm.
Brooke moved Todd away, blocking him from Nicki's reach. "Hang on, she-beast. You may like being a freak, but I do not. I want him to fix Toni and me first. How about it, Todd? Can you fix us, or do I let She-Hulk over there work you over?"
Todd squirmed in her grip and frowned. "I can't. Once something is wished, the effects are permanent. You can't unwish the results of a previous wish."
Nicki smiled and Toni wailed.
"Shut up, you cow, I'm trying to think, "said Brooke.
"But I just want to be normal, "said Toni.
Brooke suddenly brightened, as a new idea formed in her head. "You can't unwish something, but you can wish for new things. And we just want to be normal. So listen, carefully and wish exactly what I tell you. If you deviate even a syllable, I will snap your neck before you can finish. I want you to wish that all females on the planet were naturally taller and stronger than the males, that an amazon physique was normal for females, and desirable to males." Both Nicki and Toni smiled at this news.
"And I want you to wish that we were the most attractive girls at school, "said Nicki with a smile.
"Yes, "said Brooke. "That's a good idea. But make me the most attractive of the three of us."
Todd was utterly horrified.
"Do it, "insisted Nicki, pounding her fist threateningly into her palm. "Now."
"Pretty please, "said Toni, with a sad smile. "I promise we'll be nice to you."
"Do it, and you're free, " said Brooke. "Otherwise.." She turned her head and gestured towards Nicki.
Regretfully, Todd made the wish.