"Tye knew this would happen!" Brian was both shocked and angry. How could a friend do this to Mike? Except, maybe Tye wasn't their friend any more. The boy they went o school with sure did not have magical powers to transport people to other worlds, or make them into different creatures. "He sent you this way on purpose so you'd turn into a horse."
"Most centaurs know better than to come near a Wizard's town." The teen rested his chin lightly on the top of Brian's had. It was a very intimate gesture from someone Brian had never met before. "Elves, too."
"Huh?" Brian pulled away and turned to face Dar. "Is something going to happen to me?"
The homely teen grinned. "Oh, all sorts of things could happen. If you tried nursing from a mare, you'd end up a foal. There's a large pen in town where you'd end up a goat or cow. And there's a mud puddle where little kids play - you could easily join them." He stepped forward and slid a hand across Brian's chest. "Or you could join me."
Brian blinked up at Dar, his face suddenly hot. It sounded like this ugly, near-naked teenager was propositioning him. And, Brian realized, he was very attracted. Something must have shown, because Dar tugged his loincloth loose and let it fall around his ankles. The teen was spectacularly hung, the massive cock and balls looking more like what Brian would expect on a donkey or small horse. "We'd have way more fun and way less risk than fighting orcs and minotaurs and the like on some ill-fated adventure."
Dar's partially-erect black shaft was pushing out of a sheath, and Brian had reached out to feel it before he realized what he was doing. The teen just grinned when the elf snatched his hand back with a stammered 'S-sorry."
"I sure don't mind." Dar took a step closer. "Go on. Handle me all you want. If you like, you could be like me. An easy job, some magic of your own, and as much of me as you want."
Brian felt himself tremble, torn by a suddenly intense desire and ingrained fear. He'd been mostly neutral about sex back in his world, finding himself mildly interested in both girls and boys. The homosexual thoughts had been kept hidden, though. While many of his schoolmates would have no issues, society as a whole still stigmatized guys liking guys. Sure, this was some kind of fantasy world, but then this coarse-looking kid should be a handsome jock.
Except... Brian felt his pulse race when he looked at this refugee from a Neanderthal movie. He was incredibly attracted to Dar, so much so it took effort not to hug him, to explore the heavy sheath and foreskin. To be like Dar would be amazing! No pressure, no responsibility save shoveling horse shit and keeping horses happy. And magic! It was all so tempting, to give up this stupid elf charade, even give up his past life in his own world.
And that's when Brian realized that Tye had set two traps. The horses for Mike, and Dar for him. It was already obvious that Mike was well on his way to being a horse. Was Tye going to be two-for-two, setting up two of his 'friends' for failure within the first hour? He forced his hands to stay at his sides, though he did not back away from Dar. Did he really want to give in to this strange lust? Did he have any choice?