Dean was unable to speak through his rubbery mouth before the changes started again, leaving Jeff to watch as Dean continued to change. His large, erect dildo dick started to shrink quickly before popping back into Dean with a rubbery squeak, Dean tried to him his shame as the spot where his dick used to be opened up into a rubber hole, or rather rubber vagina. Following this new shift Dean began to shrink as his belly button turned inside out before pushing out into a rubber nozzle for air. When Dean was almost half the size of Jeff his body began to change ever further as Jeff watched in shock as his own dick started to tent his pants.
Dean's rubbery nipples pushed out before expanding, the rubber beneath them pushing out into large rubbery breasts as Dean's figure became much more petit and feminine. He was looking more like a living sex doll than a rubber person as he blushed in shame, not that Jeff would have noticed the blush.
But what was more noticeable was Dean's feet, his toes having merged into a single air filled rubber foot as Dean tried to hide her new shame. But as she turned around Jeff noticed a small brown bump on her rubbery rump, which quickly pushed out in a long cat like tail as two rubbery cat ears pushed out on top of Dean's head, leaving her a tiny, well endowed rubber cat girl. Slowly Dean turned to face Jeff as Jeff blushed madly, his dick tenting his pants as he looked at Dean in shock at what his secret fantasy had been.