"Now..." she said with an michievous expression. "What to do with you?.."
In my peripheral vision I saw my old dick harden again and rise up to attention... I knew it wasn't very far from the 5 inch average (because I did measure it at some point) but from this external perspective it looked kinda bigger. Something Karyn didn't seem to agree with.
"Holy shit this thing feels so..." she looked down at my old penis now standing to full attention. "so... desperate of attention. But why so small?"
"What??" I blurted surprised. The last thing expected was Karyn commenting on the size of my dick.
"What 'what'? Do you think I haven't seen a dick before?"
The truth was yes, I did not expect she would. I mean she was as nerdy and as much of a social outcast as I have been so I assumed she was also a virg...
"Well, I have seen one and I can tell you that this thing looks silly compared to Joseph's"
Oh right, she had that brief thing with Joseph, our mutual friend. But I never expected they actually got sexual during that time... Aslo, was Joseph's dick really bigger than mine or was she just toying with me becayse of what I've done to her?.. I guess that was the least of my worries.
"I wish it was 4 inches bigger." she said while grabbing it with her hand.
I stared, in awe, as my old dick grew thicker and longer, resting heavy in her hand. If previously it was weird to see my own dick from an external point of view, now it was even more surreal. That thing looked now as if it came straight out of a porn shoot.
"Karyn..." I whispered quietly only now realizing how foreign it felt to speak with her voice "please don't..."
"Shut up" she shouted taking her attention briefly away from her massive dong, which she alreadty started stroking. "You've betrayed my trust. You've destroyed the future of my body. Do you think I would want to live my life as a cum-craving, baby-producing product of your perversion? Don't think so. Besides I think I'm enjoying the ride all of your body's testosterone is giving me."
I saw my own face grin, as my old hand took the huge dick now attached to my body and begun stroking it again.
"Now excuse me as I'm gonna go and explore my manhood a bit... As for you..." she looked at the magic ring on her finger. "I wish Jon got herself cleaned up in the bathroom while also taking the opportunity to carefully examine the body that's hers now. I wish afterwards she came back to her old room and waited for me on her old bed... naked."
As if on command, I felt myself stand up, my modest boobs and bubble butt jiggling unfamiliarly as I did. Without any input from me, my body turned towards the door which I knew led to the bathroom. Before I reached it I heard Karyn's... my old... voice again.
"And Jon?" she said. "I wish that when you clean yourself up, you did your best to swallow as much of the semen you're covered with as possible. We might as well start testing the effectiveness of that 'treatment' you wished upon my old body."
Treatment? What treatme.. Oh wait. I remembered my wish from before Karyn snatched away the ring. I looked down at my smallish breasts bouncing slightly with my each step. My still-unfamiliar chest was about to start getting even more unfamiliar...