Jamie went across the apartment to see her roommate.
"Have I always looked like this?" Jamie asked.
Kelly looked up from the book she was reading. "Yeah, you've always had great tits, but you don't normally flaunt them so much."
Jamie blinked, looked down, and only then realized she hadn't put her shirt back on.
"Oh, sorry" she stammered. "I forgot. But that's not what I meant. Have I always had pointed ears?"
"Of course" said Kelly. "That's why you always dress up as a catgirl for Halloween."
Jamie had no idea what Kelly was talking about, until she did. How could she have forgotten about that? Yet that wasn't everything she had seen in her reflection. "But I've never had a tail?"
"Only with some of your costumes" said Kelly. "What's this about?"
"Can you come with me back to my room. I was seeing strange things in my mirror."
Kelly gave her roommate a look of disbelief. The Kelly shook her head and followed Jamie back to the other bedroom. Jaime sat down on the edge of her bed. A naked catgirl stared back at her.
"Tell me what you see in the mirror" said Jamie.
Kelly walked over by Jamie and looked at the mirror. Her jaw dropped. Then after the shock wore off Kelly squealed with delight.
"This is so cool! I always wondered what I would look like as a catgirl!"
So Jamie wasn't going crazy. Her reflection really was a naked catgirl. And so was Kelly's.
Kelly sat down on the bed next to Jamie. The two girls watched as their reflects held hands then turned and kissed.
Jamie gulped. She turned at looked at Kelly...and saw pointed ears peaking out of her roommate's hair. "You ears!" exclaimed Jamie.
Kelly reached up touched her ears, tentatively at first, then rubbing them gently. It felt so good! Then Kelly reached over and rubbed Jamie's cat ears. Jamie squirmed at the unexpected touch then realized how good it felt, closing her eyes to focus on the sensation. Jamie opened them again when the rubbing stopped. She found Kelly unbuttoning her blouse which was straining against bigger, firmer breasts. Jamie felt herself growing wet at the sight of her roommate's tits.
The unbuttoning completed, Kelly took Jamie's hand in hers and looked her roommate in the eyes. "The mirror says the next thing we should do is kiss."
Jamie glanced at the mirror to see the two naked catgirls in the reflection were now making out and groping each other. "The envy of any man or woman" Jamie remembered thinking earlier. She looked back at the real Kelly and made a decision.